
A Pike County special grand jury has cleared two sheriff's deputies who opened fire during a Nov. 11 confrontation on State Route 335, while indicting the man they shot, 56-year-old Chillicothe resident Anthony D. Umphries, on seven felony counts including attempted aggravated murder. Umphries remains in custody and is scheduled for arraignment in Pike County Court of Common Pleas.
Grand Jury Returns No Bills Against Officers
According to CW Columbus, Pike County Prosecuting Attorney Michael A. Davis announced the grand jury's decisions, which included declining to indict the two officers who fired their weapons during the encounter. The special grand jury returned no bills against both officers after reviewing the evidence, per Scioto Valley Guardian.
The shooting happened at about 3:30 p.m. on Nov. 11 on State Route 335 near Walkers Ridge in Pike County, the same outlet reports. The Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation's Force Investigation Unit handled the review of the officers' use of force, a standard step in officer-involved shooting cases.
What the Grand Jury Reviewed
Jurors examined body-camera footage described as showing Umphries firing at the officers before they returned fire, along with photographs of the scene, Umphries's own interview and testimony from investigators and officers, according to the same account. That evidence formed the basis for both the decision to clear the deputies and the decision to indict Umphries.
The Pike County Sheriff's Office has said deputies went to the area on a theft complaint and that dispatch had warned them Umphries was considered armed and dangerous, the station's report notes. Deputies said Umphries turned and fired at them during a chase, and that he was struck when deputies returned fire; no deputies were injured. Umphries was flown to Grant Hospital in Columbus for treatment, and his condition has not been released, per the same account.
Seven Felony Counts, Including Attempted Murder
The grand jury indicted Umphries on seven felony counts: two counts of attempted aggravated murder, two counts of felonious assault, and one count each of aggravated trafficking in drugs, aggravated possession of drugs and having weapons while under disability, according to Scioto Valley Guardian. The drug counts allege Umphries possessed about 60 grams of methamphetamine.
The indictment also carries firearm specifications on six of the seven counts and repeat-violent-offender specifications on four counts, the outlet reports. Umphries remains in custody and is scheduled to be arraigned before Judge Rob Junk in Pike County Court of Common Pleas, according to CW Columbus.









