
Pushcart Players is bringing its long-running holiday musical to a new stage this winter, teaming up with the Actors Studio of New Jersey for two performances of “Holiday Tales: A Season of Miracles” at the historic Dunellen Theatre on December 5 and December 12. The production, built around four interwoven holiday stories and original music by a Tony Award winner, marks the first theatre-for-young-audiences show the Actors Studio of New Jersey has staged at its Middlesex County home.
The partnership was announced by NewJerseyStage.com, which reported that the two companies will present “Holiday Tales: A Season of Miracles” for families and audiences of all ages. According to the outlet, the show was written and adapted by Pushcart co-founder Ruth Fost, with music arranged by Tony Award winner Larry Hochman and direction from producing artistic director Paul Whelihan. Pushcart Players describes the piece on its own site as a sparkling collection of holiday stories from different cultures, with a book and lyrics by Fost.
The story frames its four tales within a larger narrative: it begins with Clara and Fritz awaiting their family's Christmas celebration before opening a storybook, according to NewJerseyStage.com's report. From there, the show weaves together O. Henry's “The Gift of the Magi,” about a young couple and the meaning of giving; “The Kwanzaa Kite”; “The Menorah From Heaven,” adapted from a story by Eric Kimmel about villagers mistaking a farmer's hayfork for a menorah; and E.T.A. Hoffmann's “The Nutcracker,” featuring Clara's dream adventure with the Nutcracker Prince.
Where, Exactly, Is That Kite Flying?
The sourcing gets tangled on one detail. Pushcart Players' own website describes “The Kwanzaa Kite” as an original tale set in Nigeria. But NewJerseyStage.com's account of the show describes it instead as an original story set in Mozambique, about a young girl's creativity and Kwanzaa's seven principles — a detail echoed by a separate report from MyVeronaNJ, which also describes the segment as an original story set in Mozambique about a young girl's creativity and the seven principles of Kwanzaa. The discrepancy remains unresolved across the available accounts.
Beyond the geography question, the show's creative team is emphatic about its larger message. Whelihan said the production's message of compassion, generosity, courage, creativity, and love resonates beyond the holiday season, per NewJerseyStage.com. The story explores generosity, kindness, creativity, and compassion across its four tales, and is designed for families and audiences of all ages.
A New Home in a Century-Old Theater
The Actors Studio of New Jersey, founded in 2024, describes itself as a nonprofit professional theater company dedicated to producing theater, supporting artists, and expanding access to the performing arts throughout New Jersey, according to its own site. The company announced its residency at the Actors Studio of New Jersey's historic Dunellen Theatre, noting that the venue opened in 1921 and was originally designed as a 500-seat movie house — a longtime Middlesex County landmark now hosting the company's planned slate of theatrical experiences there.
Michael Restaino, founder and producing artistic director of the Actors Studio of New Jersey, said the studio is excited to welcome Pushcart Players and believes professional theater for children and families can inspire a lifelong love of the arts, per NewJerseyStage.com. For the Actors Studio, “Holiday Tales” marks its first theatre-for-young-audiences production at Dunellen Theatre.
A Cast Spanning Both Companies
Danny Sims, who has toured with Pushcart Players for eight seasons, serves as both a Pushcart Players cast member and Director of Creative Vision for the Actors Studio of New Jersey — a role confirmed on Pushcart Players' own staff page, which notes he currently serves as a creative board member as well as Director of Creative Vision for the studio. Sims said he is thrilled and proud to be a Pushcart Players company member and part of the Actors Studio of New Jersey's inaugural team in that role, according to NewJerseyStage.com. He added that live theater is special and essential for young people, and can support their growth, development, and appreciation for the arts.
The cast for the Dunellen performances includes Nikki Andrews-Ojo, Oscar Castillo, Ariella Mandel, and Sims, with Tori Riley serving as production stage manager, per NewJerseyStage.com's report. That same cast and crew lineup was separately confirmed for a public performance Pushcart Players is staging at the Theater at First Presbyterian Church of Verona on December 6 at 11:30 a.m., according to MyVeronaNJ, which also lists tickets there at $20 per person with a buy-one-get-one-free discount for Verona residents using the promo code BOGO2026VERONA.
Dates, Times and Ticket Details
At Dunellen Theatre, located at 458 North Avenue in Dunellen, doors open at 10:30 a.m. for performances beginning at 11:00 a.m. on both December 5 and December 12, according to NewJerseyStage.com. Tickets cost $20 per person and are available online for purchase, the outlet reported. The Dunellen date also appears on the New Jersey Theatre Alliance's listings, which confirm the December 5 performance at Dunellen Theater.
Pushcart Players, founded in 1974, is an award-winning professional touring theater company and a member of Actors' Equity Association that has presented musical theater productions, workshops, and residencies for students from pre-K through 12th grade for more than 50 years, per NewJerseyStage.com's account. The company brings educational and entertaining performances to schools and communities throughout New Jersey and across the country. This is not the first time audiences have been able to catch the production from home, either — Pushcart previously offered a virtual presentation of “Holiday Tales: A Season of Miracles” across several dates in November and December 2021, with Family Pass reservations priced at $25, according to an earlier NewJerseyStage.com report.









