Columbus/ Sports

RG3 Rips Desmond Howard Over Jeremiah Smith Heisman Snub, Says He's Best in Nation

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
RG3 Rips Desmond Howard Over Jeremiah Smith Heisman Snub, Says He's Best in NationSource: MMG / Wikimedia Commons

Jeremiah Smith caught 11 passes for 117 yards and a touchdown in Ohio State’s 28-19 win over Northwestern at Ohio Stadium. The performance added to his Heisman case, but the dispute between Robert Griffin III and Desmond Howard centered on a different question: whether Smith has been decisive in Ohio State’s biggest games.

Two Heisman Winners, One Heated Exchange

Griffin, the 2011 Heisman winner, posted two messages on X criticizing Howard’s treatment of Smith. “Desmond Howard has to stop hating on Jeremiah Smith just because he goes to Ohio State,” Griffin wrote, according to USA Today. Griffin also cited Smith’s national championship and accused Howard of being dishonest, saying he had dismantled Howard’s argument.

The disagreement followed comments Howard made on ESPN questioning Smith’s Heisman candidacy. “Give me one game where Jeremiah Smith, the wide receiver at Ohio State, was the difference in a big game in the last two years,” Howard said, per the same USA Today account. Howard’s challenge was about Smith’s impact in major games, not whether he had produced gaudy numbers or made highlight-reel catches.

Griffin Points to Texas, Iowa, Oregon as Evidence

Griffin cited several performances in response. Smith had 164 receiving yards in Ohio State’s Sept. 12 loss at Texas and 206 yards in an Oct. 3 win at Iowa, according to the same USA Today report. Griffin also pointed to Smith’s freshman season: Smith caught seven passes for 187 yards and two touchdowns in the win over top-ranked Oregon in the College Football Playoff, a performance detailed by Eleven Warriors.

Other examples in the USA Today report include Smith’s 144 receiving yards in the 2025 Big Ten championship game against Indiana and 157 yards in a College Football Playoff loss to Miami the prior season. In a 19-15 win at Indiana, he had 68 receiving yards and scored a fourth-quarter touchdown that proved to be the difference for Ohio State. The performances offer evidence for Griffin’s case, while Howard’s question turns on how to weigh that production against a player’s role in the outcome of a major game.

Howard Pushes Back on the Framing

Howard maintained that he was questioning Smith’s impact in the biggest games, not his ability or the school he attends. “Jeremiah Smith is an extraordinary talent. Nobody is questioning that,” Howard wrote, according to Sports Illustrated. He described the issue as whether Smith had been the defining factor in Ohio State’s most important games as a Heisman candidate.

Griffin’s position on the award was unequivocal: “If Ohio State wins out, Jeremiah Smith should win the Heisman Trophy,” he wrote, per the same Sports Illustrated account. Griffin added that Smith is the best player in the country.

Smith's Record-Breaking Night Against Northwestern

Smith’s Northwestern performance pushed his season totals to 80 catches for 1,317 yards and 15 touchdowns, according to the same USA Today report. Ohio State’s own recap, published by Ohio State Buckeyes, called Smith a “Heisman Trophy frontrunner” and said he continued his standout season; the 117 yards brought his career total to 3,875 yards, the most in Big Ten history.

The game also extended Smith’s streak of 100-yard receiving performances, though sources differ on the count. Ohio State’s recap says he has 18 career 100-yard receiving games, the most in Ohio State and Big Ten history. ESPN reported that he tied the Big Ten record with his 17th such game. Neither account resolves the discrepancy.

At the time of publication, Smith was favored to win the Heisman with his 1,317 yards and 15 receiving touchdowns, according to Awful Announcing, a status noted by that outlet alongside the ongoing Griffin-Howard dispute. Meanwhile, the broader Heisman race has been shifting elsewhere in the sport: Utah quarterback Devon Dampier's odds shortened from +2200 to +720 after the Utes improved to 10-0, as reported by FOX Sports, a reminder that Smith isn't the only name generating buzz this season.

A rare path for wide receivers

According to the Heisman, Alabama wide receiver DeVonta Smith became the first wide receiver in almost three decades to win the award, in 2020. That history underscores how uncommon a receiver’s Heisman win is; it provides context for Jeremiah Smith’s candidacy, but does not determine its outcome.