
Nearly three years after Steven Toler was found dead in a truck outside his mother's Richmond home, investigators have arrested a man they believe was connected to the drugs that killed him. Justin Kavanaugh, 43, is now charged with second-degree manslaughter and first-degree trafficking in fentanyl in a case that sat open since December 2023.
Toler was found dead in a truck at his mother's home in the 100 block of Janwell Drive on Dec. 14, 2023, according to court records cited by WKYT. He died of an overdose that year. On the day he was found, his girlfriend told the responding officer that no one had heard from him in a day, following a fight the two had over his alleged drug use.
A Name, a Phone Number and an Old Investigation
Toler's mother told officers at the time that her son had purchased drugs — suspected then to be methamphetamine — from a man known only as “Jay.” That name turned out to be the break investigators needed. Police recognized the phone number saved for “Jay” on Toler's phone as belonging to Kavanaugh, a number they knew from a previous, unrelated investigation, the station's report says.
Investigators also linked a cash-out receipt from Red Mile Gaming, found in the cab of Toler's truck, to Kavanaugh. They believed the receipt had been used as packaging for the drugs Toler obtained before his death, per the same account.
Girlfriend's Written Statement Becomes Key Evidence
The case moved forward this month when Toler's girlfriend gave investigators a written statement describing what she saw before his death. She said she witnessed Kavanaugh hand Toler a folded piece of paper after the two men had gotten high on methamphetamine together. The article notes that her statement provided a key breakthrough in the long-dormant investigation.
Still, the case against Kavanaugh carries an acknowledged gap. Investigators were not able to locate definitive evidence that Kavanaugh had actually provided the drugs that killed Toler, according to the report. The charges rest on the phone number, the receipt and the girlfriend's account rather than a confirmed hand-to-hand drug transfer.
A Familiar Name in Local Court Records
Kavanaugh is not a stranger to Madison County's court system. A Richmond Register report from an earlier case described him as a Richmond man previously convicted several times of drug trafficking. That same report said Justin “Crazy” Kavanaugh, then 30, had been indicted on a cocaine-trafficking charge and as a first-degree persistent felony offender.
Fentanyl's Toll Across Kentucky
Toler's death reflects a trend that has gripped the state for years. Kentucky recorded 1,986 resident drug-overdose deaths in 2023, a 9.7% decrease from the 2,200 deaths logged in 2022, according to the Kentucky Injury Prevention and Research Center. Fentanyl was involved in 1,389 of those deaths statewide, accounting for nearly 70% of the total.
Madison County, where Richmond is located, saw its own fentanyl-related deaths climb that year, recording 51 such deaths in 2023, up 10.9% from 46 the year before, per the center's data. No disposition, plea or trial date in Kavanaugh's current case has been reported.









