
The Buffalo Sabres have opened preliminary talks with New York State, Erie County and the city of Buffalo about a new lease at KeyBank Center, a conversation that could determine how much public money goes toward upgrading the nearly 30-year-old arena. Those discussions remain in early stages, though conditions appear favorable for progress, and any new lease could require hundreds of millions of dollars in improvements to the building, according to the article.
According to Buffalo News, the Sabres are talking about the overall vision for KeyBank Center renovations and the neighborhood around it before getting too deep into the specific terms of a new lease. The stadium public-private partnership provided a foundation for talks.
Momentum Without a Deal on Paper
A May report from Sports Business Journal found that Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz remained in communication with Guelli, but that actual lease negotiations had not been stepped up or advanced in recent months.
Still, there have reportedly been positive initial discussions between the sides. The Sabres bought themselves time to work toward a broader agreement when they announced their current KeyBank Center lease would continue through September 2031, under a five-year deal reached before last season. The arrangement gives the team the option to either continue the lease for another five years or opt out on Sept. 30. “The next five years give us a chance to discuss a long-term plan for the arena,” Guelli said, in comments shared by the Buffalo Sabres.
Erie County Wants Out of the Arena Business
Erie County owns the KeyBank Center building while the city of Buffalo owns the land underneath it, and the county has made clear it does not want to hold onto its current role indefinitely. “My goal is to eventually get the county out of that,” Poloncarz told WKBW, which reported that the county's 30-year lease for the arena expires next year and that the county is not planning to renew it.
A September report from Buffalo Business First described Erie County as looking to divest its interest in the building altogether, with experts weighing potential ownership options and noting significant economic implications for the region. The evidence does not establish who might eventually own or operate KeyBank Center once the county steps back.
Why a Deal Could Come Together Now
Poloncarz is approaching his final year in office, and the article suggests that timing may motivate him to push toward a new lease before he leaves. He has a track record on this front: Poloncarz entered formal negotiations for a new Bills stadium in 2021 and has said he took those talks seriously because the team had other options and he did not believe the matter was getting sufficient attention at the time. That stadium agreement ultimately included a 30-year commitment by the Bills to remain in Western New York.
The Sabres currently operate under the existing Erie County lease until a new long-term agreement is reached.
An Arena Due for an Overhaul
KeyBank Center opened nearly three decades before this story published and has not undergone a major renovation. Terry and Kim Pegula have spent millions of dollars improving the fan experience, including privately funding a new videoboard and a new roof, according to the team. This season's additional upgrades include a multi-million-dollar audio system along with updated security and concessions technology.
Architectural firm Populous was hired to study the arena and help shape plans for next steps; Guelli told Buffalo Toronto Public Media in 2025 that the firm was working on a study to create a long-term plan for the site. Any future improvements are intended to upgrade infrastructure and backstage areas and make the building more multipurpose, according to the article. A long-term plan, per the Sabres, would cover both the next phase of a lease agreement and additional renovations.
An Arena Filling Up Fast
KeyBank Center was expected to host 140 events in 2025, up from about 120 in past years. The Sabres themselves have said the arena hosted roughly 140 events in the past year compared with a typical average of about 120, and that the organization wants to eventually reach 200 events annually. This year, the arena is scheduled to host nearly 200 events, and the team projects 1.3 million people will pass through its doors in 2026.
A Tripp Umbach study found KeyBank Center generated a $694.2 million economic impact in 2023, supporting jobs for 3,822 people and generating $48.6 million in taxes, per the Sabres. ECHDC Chair Joan Kesner has called the waterfront essential to Buffalo's future.
A Wider Waterfront Push
The arena talks are unfolding alongside a broader state push to reshape Buffalo's waterfront. New York State is developing a new strategy for the area, with a planning zone that extends from Interstate 190 and the waterfront to Michigan Avenue and the Erie Basin Marina, including Sahlen Field. Housing work is moving forward at Marine Drive Apartments, North Aud Block and Heritage Point. A state spokesperson has said the state will consult stakeholders to ensure Canalside becomes the year-round destination it should be.
Those ambitions also raise questions about how much the city, county and state may be willing or able to commit to arena upgrades. For now, the pieces for a new KeyBank Center lease appear to be falling into place, even as the hard work of hammering out specific terms still lies ahead.









