San Antonio/ Politics & Govt

SAISD Votes to Negotiate Knox School Sale as 15 More Campuses Face Scrutiny

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
SAISD Votes to Negotiate Knox School Sale as 15 More Campuses Face Scrutiny302 Tipton Ave. — Approximate Site of Proposed Housing Project
Google Street View

San Antonio Independent School District trustees voted unanimously to let administrators negotiate the sale of the former Wilbur J. Knox Early Childhood Education Center to the San Antonio Housing Trust, which plans to convert the shuttered campus at 302 Tipton Ave. into affordable housing. The vote comes as the district has already closed 17 schools since 2023 and is now scrutinizing 15 more campuses for their future.

According to the San Antonio Express-News, Christina Martinez, who serves on the Housing Trust's board, said the Knox project will be the organization's first affordable-housing effort and that it intends to continue similar work going forward. The Housing Trust describes itself as an entity established with a $10 million corpus by the City of San Antonio and governed by a board of trustees appointed by the San Antonio City Council, according to the San Antonio Housing Trust. The Trust also says its public facility corporation structure can offer a property tax exemption that reduces operating expenses and a sales tax exemption that lowers building costs, though that description of the mechanism comes from the Trust itself.

The Knox campus sits near two notable redevelopment efforts: Confluence Park, west of the school, received a $13 million facelift in 2017, while the Lone Star Brewery complex and nearby industrial properties to the north are slated for a $575 million commercial and residential redevelopment by 2050, per the Express-News report. SAISD lawyers are also exploring using a public facility corporation structure to retain district ownership of other properties while still offering tax incentives to developers, and the district plans to hire a real estate broker to help market additional buildings for sale or lease. Chief transformation officer John Norman said the district is already talking with parties interested in partnering with the school district.

Fifteen More Campuses Under the Microscope

Monday's meeting wasn't just about Knox. Norman identified 15 campuses with low utilization or among the district's smallest footprints, the majority of them located on the east and west sides of San Antonio. The most underutilized campuses named include Baskin, Barkley-Ruiz, Ogden and Green elementary schools; Davis, Rogers and Tafolla College Prep middle schools; and Houston High School. Bowden and Young Men's Leadership Academy also made the 15-campus list. Campuses flagged among the district's smallest include Beacon Hill, Pershing, Washington and Rodriguez Montessori elementary schools, along with St. Phillip's Early College High School.

Norman was careful to note that being labeled underutilized or small doesn't automatically mean a school will close. SAISD administrators are asking trustees to weigh student enrollment, building use and condition, operating costs and academic performance before any decisions are made. Norman also said closure decisions should factor in community impact alongside the data, and that the district prefers considering a handful of recommended closures each year rather than closing many campuses all at once.

Budget Pressure Keeps Building

SAISD has shuttered more campuses than any other local school system over the past three years, and nearly 40 schools have closed across the greater San Antonio metro area in that same span, driven by declining birth rates, charter school growth and budget shortfalls that have pushed districts statewide to cut campuses and save money. Because Texas public schools receive funding based on the number of students attending class each day, enrollment losses translate directly into lost revenue. SAISD has not seen an enrollment rebound despite population growth elsewhere in San Antonio, and declining enrollment paired with rising costs has driven a budget deficit of roughly $46 million for the district, according to the San Antonio Report.

The district's building stock is aging too — the average SAISD building is 63 years old, per the same report, which also described the district's strategy as twofold: building new facilities while consolidating others. SAISD enrollment has fallen sharply over the past two decades, from nearly 57,000 students in 2003 to fewer than 45,000 by 2023, according to Texas Public Radio.

Echoes of the 2023 Closure Fight

This isn't the district's first rightsizing push. Back in September 2023, SAISD staff originally proposed closing 19 campuses, with 17 slated to shut for the 2024-2025 school year and two more the year after, according to KSAT. After community pushback, administrators trimmed that list to 15 schools, and trustees approved the final consolidation package in a 5-2 vote on November 13, 2023, cutting the district's campus count by 16 percent. An external equity report cited at the time found that previous SAISD closures had not improved student outcomes and warned they could create a “school desert” attendance zone, Texas Public Radio reported.

Trustees this time delayed approval of a broader policy framework for school closure decisions until their December meeting, with trustees and district leaders expected to keep discussing how to proceed over the next five months. SAISD plans to hold community meetings from December through March as part of that process. Trustee Ed Graza said he wanted the closure policy shaped by the results of the latest tax election, in which all mechanisms to bring additional money to SAISD failed, per the article. Trustee Jacob Ramos said he wanted to see whether statewide election results might boost public education funding enough to make some closures unnecessary, while trustee Mike Villarreal said the policy should function as a system for flagging schools that need attention and weighing other factors before any closure recommendation, with the goal of increasing quality seats for students rather than closures for their own sake.

Not Just an SAISD Problem

San Antonio ISD isn't alone in confronting these pressures. North East ISD trustees voted Monday to close three elementary schools, and South San ISD leaders have said they might need to close as many as five campuses, with community meetings expected to begin soon. The pattern reflects a broader reckoning playing out across San Antonio-area school districts as enrollment shifts and state funding formulas continue to squeeze budgets.