Cleveland/ Real Estate & Development

Sandusky Eyes $20M Overhaul of Old Value City Store Into 32 Apartments

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Sandusky Eyes $20M Overhaul of Old Value City Store Into 32 Apartments202 E. Market St. — Approximate Apartment Redevelopment Site
Google Street View

The long-vacant Value City Furniture store in downtown Sandusky could soon become a $20 million mixed-use complex with 32 apartments and ground-floor commercial space, after the city's Planning Commission signed off on a site plan for the property at 202 East Market Street. The project would stretch across five adjoining parcels, folding in the old retail building, loading docks, existing parking and two houses next door.

According to the Sandusky Register, the plan calls for 32 upper-floor apartments and street-level offices. Citizen Portal describes the commercial component somewhat differently, putting the first-floor space at roughly 14,000 square feet; the dossier does not clarify which description reflects the project's final intended use. Citizen Portal also reports that the Planning Commission's vote to approve the site plan passed 4-1 on a roll call, subject to conditions recommended by staff.

The developer behind the proposal is North Coast Design Build, a Sheffield Lake company that holds the property under an option from SSC Market St Sandusky, LLC, an entity affiliated with the Columbus-based Schottenstein Property Group, per StayTunedSandusky. Schottenstein Property Group has long owned both the building and the Value City furniture franchise, the outlet reports, citing the Sandusky Division of Planning & Zoning for the parcel breakdown. The building itself is a 19th-century landmark, according to the same report.

What Happens Next at City Hall

Sandusky's city planning staff have recommended that the Sandusky City Commission approve the proposed site plan, and commissioners could take up the proposal as soon as November 23, StayTunedSandusky reports. The City of Sandusky says its Planning Commission is responsible for deciding site-plan and off-street-parking proposals, which is the authority under which the Aug. 26, 2026, vote took place. Whether any additional city approvals are required beyond that site-plan sign-off is not addressed in the available reporting.

Part of a Broader Downtown Push

The Value City proposal lands amid a string of redevelopment efforts around Sandusky. The city sold the former Osborne School to Community Building Partners, LLC in November 2023 for conversion into affordable senior housing, with at least 20 age-restricted units planned for residents 55 and older and a $750,000 contribution from the city's ARPA funds, according to the City of Sandusky. Separately, the Battery Park Marina site, which sat empty for years before its 2023 announcement, is now the subject of a $229 million mixed-use development with housing, hotels, retail and dining that News 5 Cleveland reports could take three to five years to complete.

Those projects follow years of incremental change downtown. A 2022 report from Crain's Cleveland Business noted that Sandusky had added dozens of downtown apartments and condos since city officials adopted an ambitious bicentennial vision in 2016. The city also runs a Housing Development Accelerator, which it describes as a citywide effort to expand housing options in Sandusky.

For now, the Value City building's fate rests with the City Commission's upcoming review. If commissioners follow staff's recommendation and approve the site plan, the vacant furniture store could join Osborne School and Battery Park Marina as another marker of Sandusky's push to refill its downtown footprint with housing and commerce.