Portland/ Politics & Govt

Sandy and Three Officials Face $935K Award Over Retaliation, Jury Rules

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 22, 2026
Sandy and Three Officials Face $935K Award Over Retaliation, Jury RulesClackamas County District Attorney's Office — Reported Office Addressing Allegations
Google Street View

A federal jury has ordered the city of Sandy, Oregon, and three of its top officials to pay former interim police chief Sean Lundry $850,000 in economic damages after finding they retaliated against him for exercising his free speech rights. The jury also assessed $85,000 in punitive damages against the officials, bringing the total award to $935,000. The verdict, reached Friday, closes out a bitter legal fight that began after Lundry was passed over for the permanent chief job and later fired.

Jury Splits Damages Across City and Three Officials

The eight-member jury found Sandy, City Manager Tyler Deems, Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati and former Mayor Stan Pulliam each liable for First Amendment retaliation against Lundry, according to KPTV. Jurors awarded Lundry $850,000 in economic damages, with no noneconomic damages, payable by the city and the three officials, as reported by The Oregonian/OregonLive. On top of that, jurors tacked on punitive damages of $50,000 against Pulliam, $25,000 against Deems and $10,000 against Aprati, bringing the total award to $935,000.

The case was tried over one week before U.S. District Judge Amy M. Baggio, per the same Oregonian/OregonLive account, and jurors deliberated about five hours before returning their verdict around 5 p.m. Friday. The jury did not find in Lundry's favor on two due-process claims or on a separate state whistleblower-retaliation claim, the station's report notes.

A Police Chief Search That Went Sideways

The dispute traces back to Sandy's search for a permanent police chief. Lundry, who joined the Sandy Police Department as an officer in 2015 after working for The Dalles Police Department from 2002 to 2015, had been serving as interim chief since 2023. The city had already selected an outside candidate for the permanent job before public records requests about the selection process became an issue, and in January 2024 the city informed Lundry it had chosen another candidate, Gary Jensen, a police chief from Logan City, Utah, subject to a background check.

That decision triggered significant public backlash, according to the Oregonian/OregonLive reporting, after Jensen was accused of offering preferential treatment to Utah State University football players, a widely reported allegation. Sandy ultimately rescinded Jensen's conditional job offer after community members raised concerns about his background. Lundry, meanwhile, had helped organize public records requests about the chief selection process and criticized Sandy city leadership in a Facebook post, conduct his lawyers argued led directly to his ouster.

Leave, Investigations and a Termination

Behind closed doors, tension over the chief selection was already building. During a closed Sandy council executive session on Feb. 20, 2024, Pulliam and another council member wanted to fire Lundry and find a way to get rid of him, according to testimony cited in the Oregonian/OregonLive account. Three days later, on Feb. 23, 2024, Deems placed Lundry on paid administrative leave and referred an allegation that Lundry had destroyed public records for criminal investigation, a case the Oregon State Police then investigated.

By April 15, 2024, the Clackamas County District Attorney's Office had concluded there was no evidence Lundry had unlawfully destroyed public records and declined to prosecute him, according to The Oregonian/OregonLive. An independent administrative investigation also found no basis for any of the four allegations against Lundry, according to the Oregonian/OregonLive account. Still, the city conducted its own internal investigation into the records allegation and separate workplace-conduct claims, and the Sandy Post reported at the time that the city found there was substantiating and corroborating evidence to show that Lundry had made threats of violence in the workplace, including comments about punching Jensen. Lundry received a termination notice in June 2024 and was fired as interim chief on June 18, 2024.

Competing Arguments at Trial

At trial, Lundry's lawyers argued that city leaders conspired to fire him because he and his supporters filed public records requests tied to the chief selection, the Oregonian/OregonLive reported. Evidence presented included a text Pulliam sent to Laurie Smallwood the day after Lundry was placed on leave, suggesting she stop supporting him for chief, and Smallwood's testimony that Pulliam told her Lundry was not his guy and that he wanted someone else. Smallwood described the 2024 chief selection process as a mess.

The city's attorney, Kim E. Hoyt, countered that Lundry worked to undermine the police department and the city after being passed over for chief, and argued that his public statements while serving as interim chief were not constitutionally protected speech. Pulliam, for his part, acknowledged in a deposition that he had talked with city representatives about replacing Lundry as interim chief, and testified that he and Deems met finalist Jensen before any formal offer was made. Asked about his involvement, Pulliam said, “I get to have an opinion.”

Lundry's attorneys, Chris K. Heywood and Colin H. Hunter, said in a statement that Lundry was a dedicated public servant of over 20 years who paid an enormous price for speaking out against Sandy, adding they were honored to hold the city and its agents accountable for violating his constitutional rights and harming his career, according to the Oregonian/OregonLive report. The Clackamas County District Attorney's Office had separately ordered Sandy to release community comment cards from a public forum attended by the three finalists during the underlying records dispute.

Where Lundry and Sandy's Police Department Stand Now

Per his lawyers, Lundry was unable to find another law enforcement job in Oregon and has since moved to Tennessee, where he now works as a probation officer. Sandy eventually appointed Patrick Huskey as its police chief in August 2024; Huskey had retired from a 26-year career with the Oregon State Police before taking the Sandy job.