
Santa Clara County is going back to the drawing board on a rural zoning overhaul after hundreds of farmers, winery owners, equestrians and other residents objected to the county's initial proposal. The pushback followed the release of a draft zoning amendment in September 2025, and it was significant enough that county supervisors ordered the whole process reset.
According to San José Spotlight, the county formed a 10-member Agricultural Advisory Committee in October to help shape a new draft of the rural zoning amendment. The committee advises the county's planning department and is meant to produce a clearer, more consistent zoning plan that aligns with both the Santa Clara Valley Agricultural Plan and the county's General Plan, the outlet reports. The panel has already met three times this fall, on October 8, October 22 and November 10, with meetings open to the public.
Joe Raineri, one of the committee's members, said the original draft could have put small farms in financial jeopardy. Per Raineri, small and medium-sized farms support land stewardship, the local food supply, food diversity and the broader agricultural identity of the Santa Clara Valley. He added that any amendment needs to remain economically viable for agricultural businesses to keep operating, while also serving the county's goal of preventing incompatible development and preserving farmland.
What the County's Redo Targets
The reworked proposal, as outlined in the county's own announced plans, would limit uses within the Exclusive Agriculture zone to protect long-term agricultural viability, replace subjective local-serving provisions with objective development standards, and simplify agricultural-use rules so they line up with the Santa Clara Valley Agricultural Plan and the county's General Plan land use policies. Those zoning changes would touch the county's four agricultural zone districts: Exclusive Agriculture, Agricultural Ranchlands, Hillside and Rural Residential.
Kim Engelhardt, speaking about the process, said the planning department will return to the advisory committee's final scheduled meeting in February with concepts for formulating the amendment. Engelhardt also said the earlier draft had posed serious financial consequences for the agriculture industry — a concern that echoes what pushed the county to hit reset in the first place. No timeframe has been set for when a final draft will be ready, the county has acknowledged.
Who Pushed for the Reboot
Supervisor Sylvia Arenas requested formation of the Agricultural Advisory Committee, as did the county's Housing, Land Use, Environment and Transportation Committee. Arenas is credited with leading the Board of Supervisors' direction to reboot both the proposed policies and the community process behind them, per the reporting.
A spokesperson for Arenas' office, Patrick McGarrity, said the zoning code is updated infrequently and that changes have generally focused on just one of the four zone districts at a time. McGarrity said piecemeal updates over the years left the zoning code patched together across generations, creating disputes over what counts as “local serving” use in unincorporated parts of the county.
The advisory committee includes Anna Regalado, Jeff Martin, Greg Bozzo, Joe Raineri, Paul Kermoyan, Rachael Parakh, Rebecca Garcia, Stephen McHenry and Bill James. The county has said it plans additional public outreach as the process continues, and residents can submit public comments on the rural zoning amendment by email.
What the Earlier Draft Proposed
Coverage of the 2025 draft gives a sense of what stirred such strong objections. Winery representatives told Silicon Valley they feared zoning changes could constrain tastings, events and direct-to-consumer sales — revenue streams Engelhardt described at the time as vital to winery operations. That same reporting noted that San Benito County had rejected a similar proposal in 2024 after it was viewed as a threat to farmers.
Separately, Los Gatan reported that the earlier draft would have eliminated the separate Winery use classification entirely, dividing winery operations into individual use classifications, while also aiming to replace subjective local-serving provisions with objective development standards. Those details describe the 2025 proposal rather than the current redraft, which remains a work in progress under the new advisory committee.
The stakes for the county's farmland are long-running. Santa Clara County's planning material states that the county lost 21,171 acres of farmland and rangeland to development over the preceding 30 years, underscoring why officials describe preserving agricultural land as a central goal of the rezoning effort.









