
The U.S. Senate confirmed Colorado U.S. District Court Judge Daniel D. Domenico to a vacancy on the powerful, Denver-based 10th Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday by a vote of 51-46, according to Colorado Politics. The 54-year-old Domenico is expected to succeed Judge Timothy M. Tymkovich, a George W. Bush appointee who is taking a form of semi-retirement known as senior status.
The 10th Circuit hears federal appeals arising from Colorado, Oklahoma, Utah, Kansas, New Mexico and Wyoming, according to Colorado Politics. Colorado’s two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, voted against Domenico’s confirmation. The outlet reported that the timing of his swearing-in was not known; the court’s clerk and circuit executive had not immediately responded to a question about it.
A Career Shaped By Clerkships And Culture-War Cases
Domenico graduated from Georgetown University and the University of Virginia's law school, then clerked for Tymkovich before becoming Colorado's solicitor general under Republican Attorney General John Suthers, the same report notes. He entered private practice in 2015 and argued two cases before the U.S. Supreme Court before President Donald Trump appointed him to Colorado's federal trial court during Trump's first term.
On the district court, Domenico built a record on cases touching religion and government authority. He blocked Colorado from enforcing its abortion-reversal treatment ban against a Catholic health clinic, required the state to accept a Christian preschool into its universal pre-kindergarten program despite conflicting nondiscrimination policies, and exempted two Denver-area churches from certain early-pandemic health restrictions. He also permitted a Castle Rock church to circumvent zoning restrictions for faith-based reasons, as reported by Colorado Politics.
Domenico served as Colorado's chief district judge before stepping aside from that administrative role at the beginning of October, the report states. He is Trump's only second-term appointee to the 10th Circuit; across both of his terms, Trump has now appointed three members of that court, including Judges Allison H. Eid and Joel M. Carson III. The 10th Circuit now has 12 full-time judges, three of them from Colorado, with seven appointed by Democratic presidents and five by Republican presidents.
Senators Cite Immigration Detention Concerns
Bennet and Hickenlooper said they were concerned about Domenico’s support for broad government authority to detain people in immigration custody and his refusal to acknowledge Trump’s 2020 election loss, according to Colorado Politics. The senators cited a ruling Domenico issued this year that the government could hold people in immigration custody without bond hearings even if they had been in the country for years. In June, the 10th Circuit ruled that position was incorrect.
A separate comparison of Domenico's record against four other district judges over an eight-month span found that he ruled in fewer cases, took far longer to do so, and granted fewer petitions for those seeking release from immigration detention, according to an earlier Colorado Politics report.
A District Court Already Stretched Thin
The court is now receiving around 100 petitions a week from people challenging the lawfulness of their confinement. The influx of immigration petitions has roughly doubled the court’s overall caseload in recent months, straining both the court and the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Colorado Politics reported: Colorado Politics.
A Heavy Workload Before the Surge
The district court was already handling a comparatively heavy workload before the recent immigration-detention petition increase. Its 2024 review reported 663 weighted filings per judgeship, counting the court’s seven Article III judges and including civil and criminal filings, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado. For comparison, the U.S. Courts reported 502 weighted filings per authorized judgeship nationally in 2024. These figures cover weighted civil and criminal filings, rather than the recent stream of detention petitions.
Colorado’s district court has had its seven congressionally authorized full-time judges since 2024, but Domenico’s move to the appeals court will open another vacancy. Clerk Jeffrey P. Colwell told Colorado Politics that the court needs more full-time judges to manage its growing caseload and is considering temporary alternatives. It remains unclear how Colorado’s senators will approach filling the seat Domenico leaves behind. A spokesperson for Hickenlooper’s office said it had not decided how to approach the vacancy, while Bennet’s office did not respond to a question about reviving the judicial advisory committee the senators have previously used to vet nominees. The 10th Circuit can designate judges to other assignments within its six-state region while the district court works through its mounting backlog.
It remains unclear how Colorado's senators will approach filling the seat Domenico leaves behind. A spokesperson for Hickenlooper's office said it had not decided how to approach the vacancy, while Bennet's office did not respond to a question about reviving the judicial advisory committee the senators have previously used to vet nominees. The 10th Circuit, meanwhile, retains the ability to designate judges to other assignments within its six-state region while the district court works through its mounting backlog.









