Milwaukee/ Politics & Govt

Sheboygan Falls Voters Finally Approve School Fix After Two Failed Tries

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
Sheboygan Falls Voters Finally Approve School Fix After Two Failed TriesSource: Google Street View

Sheboygan Falls voters approved a school facilities referendum, authorizing major upgrades to a high school building that has stood largely unchanged since 1969. The measure followed two failed proposals and a reduction in the district’s requested funding.

The district announced the result directly, posting that “the Facilities Referendum has been APPROVED by voters!” according to the School District of Sheboygan Falls. Coverage of the final price tag has varied: FOX6 Milwaukee reported voters approved $65.7 million for elementary school renovations and high school renovations and expansions, while Seehafer News described it as a $68 million referendum. The district's own materials cite the $65.7 million figure, which it says carries an estimated maximum tax impact of $16 per $100,000 of property value on the debt levy.

Senior Fiona Bryant has said she hopes the improvements will support learning for current and future generations. Bryant plans to become a teacher.

A Building Stretched Thin by Growth and Age

District officials have cited the age of the facilities and limited classroom space as barriers to meeting student interest. Much of the high school still relies on its original 1969 structure, and the approved funding is intended to address those constraints.

The plan includes updates to locker rooms and renovations to the E-wing program, which offers career-path exploration and practical applications of classroom learning. The work is intended to expand space for welding, woodworking, manufacturing, agriculture and automotive classes.

What the Money Will Build

The approved funding covers a wide range of projects beyond the technical-education wing. Plans call for new science labs, STEM classrooms, culinary education spaces, and an expanded library, according to the district's project description. District materials also list modernized classrooms, an auditorium, a gymnasium, locker rooms and fitness facilities among the planned upgrades.

The scope extends to infrastructure as well: plumbing replacement and restroom updates to meet ADA accessibility requirements are included, along with improvements to student drop-off and pick-up areas intended to improve school safety. The district has said a homeowner with a $500,000 house is expected to pay an additional $80 in property tax each year as a result of the increase tied to the referendum.

Third Attempt Succeeds After Two Rejections

The approved referendum followed two defeats. The first proposal, for $99.8 million, failed in November 2024. A revised $70 million proposal failed April 1, 2025; corrected results showed 2,604 no votes and 2,493 yes votes, according to the Sheboygan Press.

How the Three Proposals Changed

The district’s account of the sequence shows a narrower plan at each step: its November 2024 proposal totaled $99.8 million across two questions; for the April 1, 2025 referendum, it reduced the plan to $70 million and dropped a separate $21.5 million question for an auxiliary gym, multi-sport field and track, according to the School District of Sheboygan Falls. The corrected April 2025 tally was 2,604 votes against and 2,493 in favor, as reported above. The third proposal, approved by voters, is the $65.7 million plan described in the district’s materials.

Pethan said the defeats prompted the board to reconsider its priorities. “After the first two didn't pass, I think our school board really needed to look at what are the absolute essentials of the needs that we have in the school district,” he said. Seehafer News reported that work on the approved updates is expected to begin next spring or summer, though a firm construction start date has not been set.

The vote came amid continued competition for school referendum support across Wisconsin. WisPolitics reported that voters approved roughly 58.1% of Wisconsin school referendums in 2026, a slight increase from the prior year but below historical highs. More than 70 Wisconsin districts had referendum questions on the November 3 ballot, per FOX6 Milwaukee.

The approved plan is the result of a multi-year effort by the district to secure funding for facilities it says need more than patchwork fixes. The district announced the result through its live feed, and TMJ4 News also reported on the referendum’s passage.