
The Oklahoma Supreme Court held that Silverhawk’s covenant barred Adewale Tawose’s short-term rental operation. The covenant limits lots to “private residence purposes only” and prohibits maintaining a store or business on a lot; the court concluded that this language applied to Tawose’s rental activity. The court’s opinion in Silverhawk Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Tawose affirmed the district court’s judgment.
What the court affirmed
The affirmed judgment includes an injunction barring Tawose from operating the rental and damages based on HOA fines and assessments, according to the court opinion. The justices did not review Tawose’s challenge to the attorney-fee award, finding that the issue had not been preserved for appellate review.
How the case reached the high court
Silverhawk’s HOA filed suit against Tawose in November 2021. Following a five-day bench trial, the district court found the rental violated the business-use restriction, found nuisance activity by some guests, and rejected Tawose’s breach-of-contract claim against the HOA. A Court of Civil Appeals panel later reversed parts of the judgment and remanded the case. The Supreme Court vacated that decision and reinstated the district court judgment, according to the opinion.
The decision’s reach
Four justices dissented. FOX 23 reported that they considered guests’ use of the home residential regardless of the length of their stays and argued that the covenant did not clearly prohibit short-term rentals. The decision turns on Silverhawk’s covenant language; it does not establish that every Oklahoma HOA may prohibit short-term rentals.
Edmond licensing is separate from HOA rules
For municipal licensing, the City of Edmond’s Permits & Licenses page lists vacation rental homes under “NO Permit or License Required.” That city licensing information is distinct from the private covenant at issue in Silverhawk.









