Philadelphia/ Politics & Govt

Sotomayor Tells Philadelphia Crowd She'd Welcome Supreme Court Term Limits

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 22, 2026
Sotomayor Tells Philadelphia Crowd She'd Welcome Supreme Court Term LimitsAmerican Philosophical Society — Host of Sotomayor Medal Event
Google Street View

Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor received the Benjamin Franklin Medal from the American Philosophical Society in Philadelphia Friday, and used the occasion to take direct aim at her own court, saying she disagreed with decisions that have expanded presidential power and that she would not be unhappy to see term limits placed on justices like herself.

A Rare Public Rebuke From the Bench

The ceremony was followed by a conversation with retired federal appellate Judge David Tatel. Speaking about her colleagues on the court, Sotomayor offered a pointed but measured critique. “I believe my colleagues genuinely believe what they're doing is what's best for the country,” she said, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer. “But,” she added, “I don't believe my colleagues are right.”

Sotomayor also addressed the prospect of structural change to the court itself. “I wouldn't be unhappy with term limits,” she said, per the Inquirer's account of the event. Separately, CNN reported that Sotomayor noted term limits were an idea “being kicked around very actively” in Philadelphia.

The FTC Ruling at the Center of Her Concerns

Much of Sotomayor's criticism centered on the Supreme Court's June decision in Trump v. Slaughter, in which the justices ruled 6-3 that President Donald Trump could remove Federal Trade Commission Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter without cause, breaking with established precedent, the Inquirer reported. Sotomayor described the ruling as destabilizing, saying it handed the president “unitary, total executive control,” according to the same report.

The decision struck down a federal law that had barred the president from firing FTC members without cause, according to SCOTUSblog's coverage of the June ruling. In her dissent at the time, Sotomayor warned that the decision would ripple far beyond a single agency. “Dozens of independent commissions are now likely to become purely executive agencies, shifting tremendous power over broad swaths of American life into the President's hands,” she wrote, per SCOTUSblog. She also concluded in that dissent that the result was “a President who emerges with far greater power than ever before,” the outlet reported.

A Congressional Research Service summary posted on Congress.gov describes the Court's holding as finding that statutory provisions limiting the president's ability to remove FTC commissioners to for-cause situations violate the Constitution, though that summary is drawn from a limited excerpt of the document.

Context for a Justice Known for Pointed Dissents

Sotomayor's Philadelphia remarks echo concerns she has raised from the bench throughout the year, as the court has handed down a string of rulings reshaping the balance between the branches of government. Her appearance came as part of the American Philosophical Society's three-day autumn general meeting, with the Benjamin Franklin Medal for Distinguished Public Service previously awarded to figures including Nelson Mandela, Margaret Thatcher and Bryan Stevenson. The society itself was founded by Benjamin Franklin in 1743 and promotes knowledge in the humanities and natural sciences, while the medal was established in 1906.

As first reported by WHYY, Sotomayor's broader remarks in Philadelphia touched on what she sees as the erosion of legal norms that have shaped the country for 250 years. She said she believed some of the court's rulings were correctly decided, though she was not always confident they were reached for the right reasons, the outlet reported.

Sotomayor's appearance in Philadelphia adds to a public record of dissent that has made her one of the court's most vocal critics of its current direction, even as she continues to serve alongside the colleagues she says got it wrong.