
A small South Side charter school serving 394 students is fighting to stay open after landing one point below the state rating that would trigger automatic closure. Royal Academy of Excellence, located at 4018 S. Presa St. in San Antonio, scored a 59 last year — just one point below a D rating — and its leaders have appealed the finding to the Texas Education Agency, arguing the state's calculation was flawed.
Royal Public Schools, which operates the K-8 campus, says the appeal centers on students who transferred to Royal midyear. According to the San Antonio Express-News, the appeal argues the state omitted several of those students' STAAR scores from its accountability calculation. Benjamin Warren said the appeal was filed over erroneous data in that calculation, and he told the paper he is optimistic it will be accepted. Warren added that Royal is simply seeking to stay open under the laws and enforcement already in place.
The stakes are stark. Texas law requires the Texas Education Agency to close a charter school that earns three consecutive F ratings within its first five years of operation, and Royal Academy of Excellence has received an F every year since 2023, including a score of 47 in the 2023-24 school year. Royal Public Schools opened in 2021 after the State Board of Education approved it in 2020, meaning the three-F threshold falls squarely within its formative years.
Who Royal Serves, and Who's Behind It
Royal Public Schools students come from low-income households at a rate of 84%, a figure that lines up with enrollment data showing 84.3% of Royal Academy of Excellence's campus population as economically disadvantaged and 91.9% as Hispanic, according to the Texas Tribune Schools Explorer. On state tests, 31% of Royal Academy students met grade level in reading, 20% in math, 22% in science, 8% in social studies and 24% across all subjects combined, per the same data.
The school was founded by Soner Tarim, who left Harmony Public Schools in 2018 to start Royal Public Schools after founding Harmony in 2000. Harmony now operates more than 60 campuses across Texas. Tarim said student mobility and challenges students face outside of school create barriers to academic achievement, and he told the Express-News it is too early to predict the outcome of Royal's appeal but that he is confident it has merit. Royal Public Schools had planned to grow from a single campus into four — two elementary schools, a middle school and a high school — though for now it operates just the one, Royal Academy of Excellence.
A Statewide Rescore, But No Guarantee for Royal
Royal's appeal lands amid a broader statewide review. The Texas Education Agency routinely reviews STAAR results each year to confirm the accuracy and fairness of the scores, and a 2026 review found that about 27,200 students statewide received additional credit for their text responses on some reading tests, according to the Texas Tribune. That rescoring is lifting ratings elsewhere: Central Middle School in Galveston ISD is set to rise six points, from a D to a 75, while Southwest ISD's overall district rating is set to climb from 79 to 80.
The Texas Tribune Schools Explorer also notes that science tests were redesigned in 2026, which likely contributed to ratings increasing statewide. Statewide STAAR results for the 2025-26 school year showed 43% of Texas students meeting grade-level expectations in math, up 1 percentage point from 2025, while reading held steady at 54%, according to the San Antonio Report. Royal is not alone in pushing back against a near-miss rating; Austin ISD has appealed two failing school ratings of its own, with Burnet missing a D by one point and Webb missing by two, according to KUT, in a bid to avoid a district-level state intervention.
What Happens Next
Whatever Royal's argument, the path for appeals is narrow. The Texas Education Agency's 2026 accountability manual states that the commissioner's rating decisions are final and not subject to further appeal or negotiation. A TEA spokesperson, Jake Kobersky, has said the agency will proceed with statutorily required closures once 2026 A-F ratings are finalized in December, leaving a tight window before Royal Academy of Excellence's fate is decided.
The dispute also unfolds against a backdrop of political pushback against the state's testing and rating system. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has vowed to eliminate the STAAR test, overhaul the accountability system, end state takeovers and replace the TEA commissioner — a broader critique of the framework Royal is now contesting one point at a time. For now, Royal Public Schools leaders are hoping that a pending appeal over student test scores will be enough to keep Royal Academy of Excellence's doors open.









