
A St. Augustine circuit judge has ruled that a Duval County private investigator cannot claim Stand Your Ground immunity in a felony gun case stemming from a January confrontation outside a home she was not even supposed to be visiting. Circuit Judge Christopher Ferebee found that Kathleen Conran pointed a gun at an unarmed man after he had already turned his back and was walking away, and that her threatened use of deadly force was not legally justified.
Ferebee issued the ruling on Nov. 13, finding that prosecutors had met their burden of proving Conran's actions did not meet the legal standard for self-defense, according to sjcitizen.com. The decision stems from a Jan. 24 confrontation on North Orange Street in St. Augustine and clears the way for Conran's prosecution on a charge of aggravated assault with a firearm to proceed. The ruling is not a finding of guilt, and it does not prevent Conran from still raising a self-defense argument when the case goes to trial.
Conran, described as a veteran Duval County-based private investigator, had asked the court to dismiss the felony gun case entirely under Florida's Stand Your Ground law, which permits deadly force only against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm. Under the statute governing that immunity claim, once a defendant raises a prima facie self-defense argument, prosecutors must overcome it with clear and convincing evidence, according to the Florida Legislature. Ferebee found that prosecutors cleared that bar at hearings held Oct. 7 and Oct. 14.
A Wrong-House Mail Dispute Sparks the Confrontation
The encounter began while Conran was attempting to serve papers in an unrelated case, approaching a home that the man renting it had no connection to her actual assignment. The man testified he saw Conran open his mailbox, remove mail and examine it; Conran acknowledged touching the mailbox but denied examining its contents. She had approached the home after speaking with people at a neighboring property, and she went on to question the man's right to occupy the house while declining to identify herself during the confrontation.
According to the account the judge found credible, Conran moved fully off the property and the man headed back toward his front door, only for him to approach her vehicle again and demand that she leave. Ferebee found that the renter's account was consistent with recorded complaints and later reports of the incident, per sjcitizen.com's reporting on the ruling.
What the Smart Glasses Allegedly Captured
Central to the prosecution's case was footage recorded by Meta smart glasses Conran was wearing during the confrontation. Prosecutors argued that the recording shows Conran drawing her gun only after the man had turned his back and was walking away, according to a separate report from sjcitizen.com. Ferebee's ruling reflects that same sequence: the man turned away before Conran raised her gun, and she has acknowledged threatening to kill him while his back was turned.
Conran's defense offered a different framing, arguing that the man had confronted her aggressively and followed her toward her truck, and that she drew the weapon because she reasonably feared an attack. The judge, however, found that the man had no weapon and did not threaten violence, even while acknowledging that he was angry, spoke loudly and used profanity during the encounter. Per the same reporting, Ferebee also considered Conran's age, prior surgeries and physical limitations in weighing her claimed fear, but still concluded the threatened force was unjustified.
Judge Rejects Claim That Gun Was Merely Displayed
Ferebee specifically rejected the argument that Conran had merely displayed her weapon rather than threatened deadly force, finding instead that pointing the gun while threatening to shoot the man constituted threatened deadly force under the law. That finding, paired with the determination that the man posed no imminent threat once he had turned and begun walking away, formed the basis for denying immunity.
The ruling does not determine Conran's guilt. It simply means the aggravated assault with a firearm prosecution against her can move forward, with prosecutors still required to prove their case at trial. Conran remains charged, not convicted, as the case heads toward its next stage in the St. Augustine court system.









