
A St. Francisville couple accused of beating their adopted daughter with sticks, firewood and a metal baseball bat is now headed to prison after changing their pleas this week to avoid trial. Gretchen Hanchey was sentenced to 18 years, with all but four years suspended, while her husband Glenn Hanchey received 10 years, with all but two years suspended.
On Thursday, the Hancheys changed their pleas to nolo contendere, or no contest, as part of a deal that kept the case from going to trial, according to unfilteredwithkiran.com. The outlet reported that Gretchen Hanchey was arrested Sept. 26, 2025, and Glenn Hanchey on Nov. 12, 2025. Both had initially pleaded not guilty, per The Advocate. Both were remanded to state custody immediately after Thursday's hearing, the outlet reports.
Once released, each will serve five years of active supervised probation, during which they are barred from contacting the victim, the same report notes. The case centers on the Hancheys' adopted daughter, who is Glenn's biological niece — the couple are described as the girl's aunt and biological uncle.
Conflicting Accounts of When the Adoption Took Place
Reporting diverges on exactly when the adoption occurred. The Advocate's court-record reporting states the Hancheys adopted the girl in 2018, when she was 4 years old, while a separate account from unfilteredwithkiran.com says the adoption happened in 2020. The available records do not resolve which date is accurate.
What is clear is what happened after the couple brought the girl to the Tupelo Children's Mansion, a children's group home in Mississippi, in February 2024, as The Advocate first reported. Staff there documented injuries and told investigators the child recalled being struck with sticks, firewood and metal baseball bats. According to a Mississippi Department of Child Family Services report, the child said most of the abuse came from Gretchen Hanchey.
Scars, Chipped Teeth and a Hospital Stay
Group home staff reported finding scarring on the child's face, nose and lips, along with chipped teeth and blood collected between her ear cartilage and skin — an injury normally resulting from blunt force trauma, according to The Advocate's reporting. The girl was also admitted to a hospital and treated for cranial swelling during her stay at the group home, the outlet notes.
The Hancheys reportedly told staff that the girl's scarring came from a car accident while she lived with her biological parents. But staff who reviewed her adoption application photo said they saw no lip scarring in that image, raising questions the family's explanation did not answer. The girl also told staff she remembered undergoing multiple plastic surgeries in Baton Rouge, and when staff asked for medical records, the Hancheys reportedly provided documentation only of a cleft palate surgery.
A Welfare Check That Took Months to Reach Louisiana
A Louisiana Department of Children & Family Services report said law enforcement first contacted Mississippi child protection authorities about the case in July 2025 — months after the girl's injuries were documented at the group home in early 2024. A separate DCFS hotline report about the girl, received in January 2024, had been assessed as not meeting the legal criteria for an investigation, with no action required at the time, per unfilteredwithkiran.com's review of the intake disposition.
Louisiana's child welfare agency has since said it changed its procedures. Starting November 5, the department said it would quickly connect local law enforcement to any call involving a child wellness check so that reports can be transferred for follow-up — a shift the agency described directly in comments reported by the same outlet.
The case, which unfolded in St. Francisville, has drawn scrutiny over how long it took for warning signs to translate into action across two states' child welfare systems. For now, the Hancheys remain in state custody as they begin serving their sentences, with no contact with the girl allowed once they are eventually released.









