
A long-vacant Rite Aid at Hopkins Square in Amherst could soon become a Starbucks, but the plan to rezone the property and add a drive-thru just steps from Williamsville North High School has triggered pushback from neighbors worried about traffic. Benderson Development is seeking town approval to convert part of the former pharmacy building at Hopkins and Dodge roads into a coffee shop.
According to The Buffalo News, the proposal calls for a drive-thru with room for 11 vehicles, 34 parking spaces and an outdoor patio, with the Starbucks location using the building's existing drive-thru window. The retail building would sit on 0.67 acres at the northern end of the 7-acre Hopkins Square plaza, a shopping center that already includes a swim school, a bocce club pizza spot, and Japanese and Chinese restaurants among its tenants. The proposal would redevelop the former Rite Aid building.
Benderson has asked the Amherst Town Board to rezone the property from Neighborhood Business to General Business, and the Town of Amherst lists the request, covering roughly 1.38 acres under project Z-2026-08, as scheduled for Planning Board action. The town's current zoning is intended to accommodate neighborhood-oriented commercial, professional office and personal-service needs, while the proposed zoning would allow for commercial uses serving a broader market area and community-wide needs.
Why Benderson Says the Site Makes Sense
James A. Bagnall, Benderson's director of right-to-build for the Northeast, said the company sees an appropriate opportunity to restore the property to productive commercial use, the same report from the Buffalo paper notes. Benderson has said the plan reuses an existing property rather than developing a new site, and the company cited the coffee shop's proximity to the high school and surrounding neighborhoods as a selling point. The developer has argued the project would complement existing commercial uses and serve nearby residents, school employees and surrounding business patrons, adding that the shop may serve neighborhood-scale needs despite what it called an isolated location within the plaza.
Not everyone in the neighborhood is convinced. Some residents have raised concerns that additional vehicles could worsen traffic at the busy Hopkins-Dodge intersection, particularly around school start and dismissal times, per the same Buffalo News account. Residents have also pointed out there is no left-turn signal from Hopkins Road to Dodge Road. School start and dismissal times are a particular concern. The proposal has prompted discussion in the community.
What the Traffic Study Found
To address the concerns, Benderson submitted a traffic study prepared by Passero Associates and a separate analysis of noise impacts on nearby houses. Passero Associates' project description says its study collected data at numerous Western New York coffee shops and considered traffic generation and drive-thru operations, per Passero Associates, whose project description notes that trip-generation data can vary by brand. The study examined traffic and noise impacts.
The project remains under review. An earlier account from Buffalo Business First similarly described Benderson's request to rezone the former Rite Aid property to allow for a coffee shop in part of the building.
A Cautionary Tale Down the Road
Skepticism about drive-thru coffee traffic isn't coming out of nowhere in the town. A newer 7 Brew location at Maple Road and North Bailey has been tied to backups as cars wait to enter its driveway, according to WKBW, which reported the chain has built a following on social media, especially among younger customers. Amherst Town Supervisor Shawn Lavin told the station, “I just don't like that there's lingering traffic in the center lane of that intersection. That part's a safety concern of mine.” 7 Brew has confirmed plans for more locations in Hamburg, Niagara Falls, Lockport and other surrounding communities, meaning drive-thru coffee traffic is likely to stay a live issue in the region regardless of how the Hopkins Square plan is resolved.
Other communities have wrestled with similar tradeoffs. In Greenfield, Massachusetts, a Planning Board unanimously approved a Starbucks site plan with a 14-vehicle drive-thru queue at a former Friendly's site, according to The Recorder. A traffic study there projected 143 more vehicle trips than the old restaurant drew during weekday peak morning hours and 176 more trips during peak Saturday evenings, and the approval came with conditions requiring native landscaping and two-way drive-thru entrances and exits at both ends of the property. Those details offer a point of comparison for what traffic mitigation can look like elsewhere, though they don't predict how Amherst's Planning Board will ultimately weigh the Hopkins Square proposal.









