New York City/ Politics & Govt

Success Academy Wants 617 More Seats in Bensonhurst, Seth Low Parents Push Back

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Success Academy Wants 617 More Seats in Bensonhurst, Seth Low Parents Push BackI.S. 096 Seth Low — Shared School Building At Dispute
Google Street View

Success Academy has filed an application to add 617 students and stretch its Bensonhurst campus from a K-4 school into a full K-8, and the news has unsettled families at the public middle school it has shared a building with for years. Parents say mornings at the shared entrance are already crowded, with drop-offs backing up and students getting limited time in certain shared spaces.

The application, reported by News 12 Brooklyn, would expand Success Academy Charter School – Bensonhurst's enrollment by 617 students and extend its grade levels from kindergarten through fourth grade up to eighth grade. The charter school and I.S. 096 Seth Low currently operate under one roof, a public middle school that, according to InsideSchools, draws zoned students from Bensonhurst, Gravesend and Coney Island.

Jay Brown, president of Community Education Council District 21, told the station there is no room for additional students in the building and said he opposes the expansion because the area does not need another middle school. Brown argued that Seth Low has climbed from a struggling school a decade ago into one that should serve as a citywide blueprint, and that further charter growth undercuts that progress, per the station's report.

Union and Charter Trade Sharp Statements

Adam Shapiro, the United Federation of Teachers' district representative, sent a statement to the outlet arguing that if the expansion does not end Success Academy's co-location at Seth Low, the needs of those public-school students are being pushed aside. A Success Academy spokesperson pushed back hard, saying the union is misrepresenting facts to Seth Low parents while pushing to evict Success Bensonhurst students, the same report notes.

Success Academy maintains its application proposes no change to the shared facility's space allocation, and that its new Bensonhurst middle school will not open inside the Seth Low building at all. Instead, the charter network says the expanded middle school will be located at 7801 Bay Parkway, also in Bensonhurst, with the 617 additional seats tied to that site rather than the shared facility. Success Academy has framed the move as giving its elementary students a path to continue their education within the network.

A Building With a History of Friction and Fixes

This is not the first time Success Academy's presence at Seth Low has stirred controversy. Back in 2013, the charter network applied to co-locate an elementary school inside I.S. 96 Seth Low, with the arrangement slated to begin in September 2014 if approved, according to The Brooklyn Home Reporter. At the time, Seth Low students and school leaders warned that co-locating would crowd hallways and compromise the integrity of the school's learning structure.

Yet by 2016, the two schools had found some common ground. A Chalkbeat report from that year found Success Academy Bensonhurst and I.S. 96 Seth Low had shared the building since 2014 and had developed a weekly Reading Buddies program, with older students reading to kindergarten, first- and second-graders at Success Academy. It's a reminder that co-located schools in the city have sometimes moved from conflict toward collaboration, even if this round of expansion is reopening old tensions.

What District-Wide Numbers Do and Don't Show

District 21 enrollment data complicate any simple story about crowding. NYC Public Schools' Office of District Planning reported that District 21 had 228 excess middle-school seats districtwide for 2025-26, but Sub-District 2, which includes Bensonhurst, had a deficit of 166 seats. A 2023 district report had separately estimated 622 excess middle-school seats districtwide, though that figure excluded charter enrollment and capacity entirely.

The same 2025-26 data summary counted 16 over-utilized buildings across District 21, though it does not specify whether the Seth Low building is among them. District enrollment overall has been shrinking, falling 3% to 33,202 district-school students in 2025-26 from 34,162 the year before, even as charter enrollment among District 21 residents in grades K-5 climbed 28% over the same stretch, from 1,433 students in 2020-21 to 1,835 in 2025-26.

That tension between shrinking district rolls and growing charter demand echoes a citywide pattern. A recent Chalkbeat report found 72 of the city's high schools with fewer than 250 students sit on shared campuses amid declining enrollment citywide, with some schools, like six small programs on the Lehman High School campus, choosing to align bell schedules in 2016 so students could take courses across the shared building.

Success Academy's ties to Bensonhurst real estate run deeper than the shared Seth Low building. The charter network bought 7801 Bay Parkway and the adjacent 7815 Bay Parkway from Magen David Yeshivah for $37.2 million in June 2024, according to Commercial Observer. That purchase is the site Success Academy now points to as the planned home for its expanded middle school, separate from the building it shares with Seth Low.