
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear an appeal over whether Colorado lawmakers violated free speech rights by cutting off witnesses who refused to use a transgender person’s correct name and pronouns during a 2024 legislative hearing. The justices gave no explanation for turning away the case, leaving a lower court’s ruling in place.
The appeal came from Gays Against Groomers and other challengers following a dispute with Colorado lawmakers over testimony on Tiara’s Law, a bill designed to make legal name changes easier for some people with felony convictions, according to Lehighvalleylive.com. Speakers opposing the bill were cut off after lawmakers said they had misgendered a transgender person, according to the Epoch Times. As the Advocate reports, the dispute traces to the 2024 hearing, where Rich Guggenheim and Christina Goeke say lawmakers interrupted their testimony after they refused to use the transgender person’s correct name and pronouns. Goeke additionally alleged that portions of her testimony were removed from the legislative record.
How the Case Moved Through the Courts
A federal judge ruled that the Colorado legislators were protected by legislative immunity, and a federal district court dismissed the lawsuit in November 2024, per the Advocate’s reporting. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision in March, finding that legislative immunity protected lawmakers’ authority to establish and enforce rules for their own hearings, the outlet notes.
The challengers then asked the Supreme Court to review questions involving legislative immunity and the restrictions placed on public testimony, arguing that lawmakers violated their First Amendment rights by controlling how they could speak. An amicus brief filed in the case supported the challengers’ arguments, according to Supreme Court records. On Monday, the justices rejected the appeal without comment, leaving intact the federal appeals court ruling that shielded the five Democratic state lawmakers from the lawsuit, the Advocate reported.
Attorney Voices Disappointment
Del Kolde, an attorney with the Institute for Free Speech, which represented the plaintiffs, said the group was unhappy with the outcome. “We’re disappointed that the Court declined to take up this case,” Kolde told the Advocate.
The decision ends the case without settling whether restrictions on misgendering violate the First Amendment, the same outlet notes, and the Supreme Court did not establish a nationwide rule on whether governments may restrict misgendering or deadnaming during public hearings. That broader First Amendment debate remains unresolved, according to the Advocate’s reporting.
A Legal Backdrop Shaped by Bostock
The case sits against a wider legal backdrop shaped by the Supreme Court’s 2020 ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, which held that federal workplace protections against sex discrimination include discrimination based on transgender status. Later courts have continued confronting separate questions involving misgendering and deadnaming, though Monday’s order leaves the lower-court result in Colorado’s case intact without resolving how those questions apply to legislative testimony.









