New Orleans/ Crime & Emergencies

Treme Man, 22, Pleads Insanity in Fatal French Quarter Carjacking of Uber Driver

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Treme Man, 22, Pleads Insanity in Fatal French Quarter Carjacking of Uber Driver1000 Bienville St. — Reported Site of Fatal Carjacking Homicide
Google Street View

The Treme man accused of carjacking and killing an Uber driver in the French Quarter last year has changed his plea to not guilty by reason of insanity, arguing a traumatic brain injury from a 2019 car wreck left him unable to tell right from wrong. Brandon “Bee” Joseph, now 22, is accused of fatally carjacking 60-year-old Miguel “Nation” Stemley on Bienville Street in October 2025, and has remained jailed on a $3 million bond since his arrest that month.

Joseph switched his plea in the second-degree murder case this month, according to NOLA.com. Stemley died when his SUV overturned and pinned him underneath during the carjacking, per the outlet's reporting. The New Orleans Police Department identified Joseph as the carjacker seen jumping into Stemley's running rideshare vehicle, using footage pulled from the city's real-time crime center camera network, the report states.

Under Louisiana law, a defendant is exempt from criminal responsibility if, because of a mental disease or defect, they were incapable of distinguishing right from wrong with reference to the conduct in question, according to the Louisiana State Legislature. The burden falls on the defendant to establish that defense by a preponderance of the evidence, per a separate statute from the same legislature. State law also allows a defendant to withdraw a not-guilty plea and enter a combined not-guilty and not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity plea within ten days of arraignment, with courts able to permit later changes for good cause, according to the legislature's published text.

A Crash Six Years Before the Carjacking

Joseph's public defender, Drew LaFontant, has argued the case traces back to a 2019 crash, when Joseph was 15 years old, the station's report notes. LaFontant sought to introduce Joseph's medical records from a three-week stay at University Medical Center and Children's Hospital New Orleans following that crash, according to the same account. Forensic psychiatrist Sarah DeLand was hired by Tulane University to evaluate Joseph, and LaFontant sought a postponement because DeLand was unavailable, per the report.

Prosecutors have pushed back hard on how that 2019 injury should factor into the case. Matthew Derbes, who heads District Attorney Jason Williams' specialized homicide unit, said Joseph's crash injuries came after he stole a vehicle, the outlet reports. State prosecutors have argued jurors should not hear the brain-injury evidence at all, contending Joseph was injured while attempting a teenage carjacking at the time of that earlier wreck.

Derbes also argued in a legal filing that Joseph's defense team had held some of the medical records for nearly a year before trial, according to the same reporting. LaFontant filed motions this month tied to Joseph's scheduled trial date, per the report.

Co-Defendant's Case Also Delayed

Angel Martinez, a 20-year-old New Orleans East man, was charged with second-degree murder and accessory after the fact in connection with the case. Prosecutors allege Martinez helped Joseph during the carjacking, though Martinez has pleaded not guilty, the outlet notes. His trial has been reset for March 2027, the same account states.

District Judge Simone Levine reset Joseph's trial to March as well, according to the reporting. Levine is set to leave the court before that trial takes place because her seat was lost to legislative cuts, per the same source.

In the days after the killing, NOPD sought public help locating three persons of interest in the homicide investigation tied to the October 9, 2025, killing on the 1000 block of Bienville Street, according to the report. Both Joseph's and Martinez's cases are now expected to move toward trial next spring.