Treasure Valley/ Food & Drinks

True-Crime Podcast Hosts Bring Oh No Bagels to Boise

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 12, 2026
True-Crime Podcast Hosts Bring Oh No Bagels to BoiseSource: Shisma / Wikimedia Commons

Oh No Bagels, founded by Garrett Moreland, is headed to Boise. The shop has leased space in a building under construction at 3152 E. Barber Valley Dr., bringing its bagels and rotating specialty menu to the Boise area for the first time.

The lease was reported by BoiseDev. According to the outlet, Garrett Moreland began making bagels at home for family and friends in 2020, learning as he went. The shop’s website describes its process this way: “Rolled the day before. Boiled and baked each morning.”

From a Home Kitchen to a Lehi Storefront

On the shop’s website, Garrett Moreland wrote that the home-baking effort grew into a Lehi storefront six years later. The Utah shop serves bagels, schmears, and coffee, with specialty items that rotate through the menu.

Utah business entity records show that Oh No Bagels LLC is controlled by Garrett Moreland.

A Podcast Side Hustle That Found Netflix

The Morelands also run Oh No Media, which produces the true-crime podcast Murder with My Husband. On the show, Payton researches and presents cases while Garrett responds, according to the podcast’s about page.

BoiseDev reported that Netflix added Murder with My Husband to its service earlier this year. Moreland also told the outlet that he and Payton planned to keep recording episodes over the following months while he baked bagels and worked on the Boise shop.

Barber Valley's Growing Food Scene

The Barber Valley building is part of an area attracting commercial development. Nearby, Barber Investments applied to build an 8,000-square-foot commercial building at 3140 E. Barber Valley Drive, with four tenant spaces and onsite parking; the owner expected businesses to open there in early 2027, the Idaho Statesman reported. The report also described a draft Harris Ranch plan with 316 apartments near retail centered on food, a hotel and market to the south, and 66 townhomes to the north.

A Mixed-Use Vision for Barber Valley

The City of Boise’s Barber Valley Specific Plan envisioned Barber Station as a mixed-use area, according to the City of Boise.

Whether Oh No Bagels ends up with neighbors from that same wave of development remains to be seen, but the planned shop will add another specialty food option to a corner of Boise that's been steadily filling in with new construction. For now, fans of the Morelands' podcast will have two reasons to keep an eye on Barber Valley: fresh bagels, and whatever true-crime case comes next.