
A developer wants to buy a nearly century-old building on Waukesha's Maple Avenue, tear it down, and put up a three-story, 53-unit apartment building in its place. The proposal targets 222 Maple Ave., the former Waukesha School District administrative office building, which sits on 2.42 acres currently owned by Carroll University as it works through a sale.
The Pitch From Spoerl Commercial
Spoerl Commercial LLC would purchase the property and build a three-story, 53-unit apartment building on the site, according to The Freeman. The deal would only move forward if the company gains city approvals, as reported by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. The same report describes the plan as involving the demolition of the nearly century-old building, which has sat vacant for several years.
That characterization runs up against an official state record. A Wisconsin Historical Society property listing states that the Maple Avenue facility currently serves as offices for the Waukesha School District, a discrepancy that remains unresolved between the two sources. What's not in dispute is the building's age: the historical society's record notes the facility reflects four primary periods of construction dating between 1930 and 1965, with the original two-story brick portion featuring Collegiate Gothic styling and completed in March 1931 as a $60,000 project. The Waukesha Preservation Alliance says that original 1930 section was built for the Waukesha Vocational School.
City Weighing a Land-Use Change, Not a Final Decision
Waukesha's Plan Commission recommended a land-use change for the site on Oct. 27, with rezoning to come in later proceedings.
Waukesha community development director Jennifer Andrews has said the city needs housing, citing extremely low vacancy rates and high prices across the housing market, including for rentals. That pressure isn't new: a 2017 housing survey tabulated in early 2018 had already found a need for different types of housing at varying price points, according to a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel archive report.
Preservationists Push for Tax Credits Instead of a Wrecking Ball
The Waukesha Preservation Alliance opposes demolishing the building and has expressed interest in saving at least part of it. The group says the building is eligible for both federal and state historic tax credits, and it points to the Oconomowoc School Apartments as a model, noting that project created 55 apartments inside a former school building using those same credits.
Mayor Halvensleben has acknowledged the appeal of that approach but flagged a steep obstacle: even factoring in the available tax credits, repurposing the existing building would leave a financial gap of roughly $4 million. Spoerl has countered that its own plan could still deliver affordable housing, citing a Wisconsin Housing and Economic Development Authority allocation plan that gives Waukesha County a competitive scoring boost in the statewide tax-credit competition because the county hasn't received a recent award.
A Decade-Old Cautionary Tale Nearby
Waukesha has seen a similar proposal before. A decade before this proposal, Fox Head Residences, a much larger apartment plan for a 3.4-acre site across the street, fell flat, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel archive.
The archived Journal Sentinel report says Fox Head was first proposed with 260 apartments, while a separate account relayed by the Journal Sentinel via Yahoo News describes a later plan with 245 units. The earlier proposal also put density and rezoning on the table along Maple Avenue.
For now, the 222 Maple Ave. building's fate hinges on the city's rezoning discussion and the still-unresolved tension between preservationists who want it saved and a developer betting that new construction, backed by state housing-credit incentives, is the more realistic path to easing Waukesha's housing crunch.









