Western New York/ Politics & Govt

Williamsville’s $2 Million Plan Would Return Water to Island Park

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Williamsville’s $2 Million Plan Would Return Water to Island ParkPark Creek Footbridge
Gennady Zakharin / Unsplash

Williamsville has a $2 million plan to retire the roughly 90-year-old Ellicott Creek dam as a working structure and put a shallow flow back around Island Park, where much of the creek’s west channel has gone dry.

The village intends to remove the dam and install a passive weir system. New York State awarded a $2 million grant for the work in late October, The Buffalo News reported. Engineering design, applications and permits were next steps after the alternatives were presented. Officials estimate the project could be finished in about three years.

Water on One Side of the Island

The west channel around Island Park is the creek’s original path. The east channel formed later. An earlier engineering study put it more bluntly: at one time Ellicott Creek consisted only of the west channel around the island, The Amherst Bee reported.

That geography is now reversed in practice. Since the gates came off, most of the water has run through the east channel and left much of the west channel dry, according to WKBW. The current plan aims to restore water to the west channel, improve water quality, bolster wildlife habitat, and limit erosion in the eastern channel. Those are project aims, not results already in the creek.

The village’s pitch is modest water, not a restored millpond. A shallow flow would not hide the bed. It would, if the design works, stop treating one side of Island Park as the creek and the other as a dry ditch.

A Dam Nobody Could Safely Run

Village public works employees used to raise and lower five heavy gates by hand. The gates became inoperable and unsafe and were removed in 2020.

The shutdown did not end the argument over what to do next. In July 2022 the Village Board voted to make emergency repairs. The work was never done, The Buffalo News later reported. By March 2023 the village said it would leave the dam out of operation for a second year in a row while the debate over its fate continued.

Keeping a 90-year-old gate dam in service would have meant sending workers back onto deteriorated concrete and tracks. Leaving it idle sent the water one way and left the original channel without it. Neither choice aged well.

Flood Complaints and a Dry Bed

The interests on either side of the dam have not lined up. Upstream homeowners have complained about flooding when the dam is in use. The dried-out creek bed has affected waterfront businesses.

The debate has involved residents’ riparian rights and effects on businesses. The late-October state grant, at $2 million, matches the figure the village has attached to the plan.

A passive weir system is the proposed approach. Whether its flow satisfies either camp is a question the finished channel will have to answer.

Cheaper Options, Then a Larger Plan

The village did not arrive at this package in one meeting. On May 27, 2025, the Village Board heard results of an engineering study on ways to deal with the dam and the two channels. Residents spoke. The board did not pick an option that night.

One studied alternative would remove the dam, build a new weir in the east channel, and excavate the west channel, at an estimated $700,000. Another would do that work and add a flood bench, at an estimated $1.3 million. An earlier Buffalo News account said a study was underway: The Buffalo News reported.

The plan now on the table is larger than those study estimates and more specific about how water will be divided. The village intends to remove the dam and use a passive weir system to manage the flow. WKBW has described the work as removing the dam and dredging so water can divide between the branches.

Design Work Ahead

The grant supports design and other work over the next few years.

Officials estimate the whole effort will take about three years. The project remains in planning, with design work still ahead.

Island Park remains an island with most of its water on one side. Design work is the next step toward dividing flow between the branches.