Run, Spot, Run: Park Service Drops Plans To Update GGNRA Dog Rules

Photo: Alex Chaffee/Flickr
By Shane Downing - Published on October 19, 2017.

Dogs, dog owners and professional dog walkers have something to wag their tails about today.

The National Park Service (NPS) announced today a permanent end to its efforts to restrict off-leash dog walking within the Golden Gate National Recreation Area (GGNRA), which includes Baker Beach, Crissy Field, Fort Funston, Lands End and Ocean Beach.

It’s taken roughly 15 years of planning to get to this point, with environmental activists and dog owners at odds over the proposed dog management rules in the GGNRA.

Canine advocates fought to preserve off-leash space for their pooches, while conservationists wanted to reduce those areas to protect endangered wildlife habitats and enhance public safety.

Photo: Daniel Hartwig/Flickr

Had the rules been approved, the number of dog-accessible beach miles would have dropped from 7.2 to 2.8, and the number of trail miles would have dropped from 74 to 47. (In total, the GGNRA oversees 8.8 miles of beaches and 137 miles of trails that span Marin, San Francisco and San Mateo counties.)

The regulations were set to be finalized this year, but the NPS was ensnared in scandal that left the rulemakers in a doghouse of their own making.

Photo: trophygeek/Flickr

After the GGNRA proposed its final management plans in January, WoofieLinks.com published documents allegedly revealing an agency bias against dog owners during the rule-making process.

The information was reportedly obtained through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, leading dog owners to file a lawsuit after irregularities in the decision-making process were uncovered.

As Bay City News reports, documents obtained case showed a biased decision-making process and extensive use of private emails by five NPS officials to collude with groups lobbying for the rules, according to Andrea Buffa, a member of dog advocacy group Save our Recreation.

Photo: Mitchel Jones/Flickr

The NPS launched an independent review and concluded that the use of personal email by its employees to conduct official business was inappropriate; however, according to the Park Service, the emails allegedly didn’t influence the outcome of the planning and rulemaking process.

That said, they decided not to move forward with the proposed management plan under the circumstances.

Photo: bambe1964/Flickr

"We can do better and in the interest of upholding the highest standard of transparency and trust with our Bay Area neighbors, we have determined that it is no longer appropriate to continue with the current dog management rulemaking process at Golden Gate National Recreation Area," said NPS acting director Michael Reynolds in a statement.

The NPS first attempted to enforce new restrictions on on- and off-leash dogs in 2002, but a 2005 court decision forced officials to initiate a lengthy rulemaking process and environmental review of the proposed management plan — something vehemently opposed by a number of San Francisco elected officials.

Photo: 50-phi/Flickr

Last month, Rep. Jackie Speier (D-San Francisco, San Mateo) passed an amendment through the House that would restrict the NPS's ability to restrict off-leash dog walking in GGNRA.

The amendment, which received bipartisan support, was attached to HR-3354, a 2018 budget appropriations bill for the Department of the Interior and related agencies.

Along with today’s announcement, NPS officials said they will continue to enforce existing pet regulations dating back to 1979, with minor modifications for areas of Crissy Field and Ocean Beach.

Jan 22, 2021
San Francisco Twin Peaks

SFMTA proposes reopening most of Twin Peaks to vehicle access

SFMTA staff are recommending reopening more than half of Twin Peaks to cars, despite broad public embracement of the park for non-vehicle recreation. Read More

Jan 19, 2021
San Francisco Chinatown

$1.9 Million Chinatown relief measure passes Board of Supervisors

The Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a relief measure that would pay ailing Chinatown restaurants nearly $2 million to serve up meals for their neighbors in need. Read More

Jan 19, 2021
San Francisco Tenderloin

The Tenderloin used to have a bar where a woman was convalescing in a bed behind a curtain in back

An autobiographical essay titled "The Hard Crowd" by novelist Rachel Kushner, published in last week's New Yorker, offers some vivid snapshots of several long-gone Tenderloin bars, including one with a convalescing person in a bed in back. Read More

Jan 19, 2021
San Francisco Castro

Milk Club holds MLK Day tribute at Castro's 'Hibernia Beach' honoring community leaders

Yesterday the Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club (Milk Club) held a Martin Luther King Jr. Day tribute at Castro's Bank of America (501 Castro St.), commonly referred to as 'Hibernia Beach,' honoring the civil rights icon and the passing of recent community members. Read More