Group sues to stop historic Telegraph Hill restaurant from reopening

Photo: daderot/Wikipedia

By Nathan Falstreau - Published on July 19, 2018.

A planned revival of a nearly century-old restaurant on Telegraph Hill has been delayed by a lawsuit pending against the city, according to court documents. 

The litigation filed by Friends of Montgomery Street — a nonprofit unincorporated association — alleges that the city violated the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).  

In 2012, small business owner and Telegraph Hill resident Paul Scott purchased the building hoping to revitalize the restaurant, which has been closed since 2007. 

Julius' Castle in 2011. | Photo: Gary Stevens/Flickr

Last February, he filed for a conditional use authorization, but SF Planning determined that any moves to reopen the restaurant were exempt from environmental review, according to the documents.

"Because the proposed project satisfied the criteria for an exemption for conversion of small structures, no environmental review of the project was required," reads a response from the City Attorney's Office

In July, the Planning Commission considered the conditional use authorization, with community members speaking both in favor and against the project. Ultimately, the commission voted unanimously to approve the restaurant's return, affirming that it was categorically exempt from a CEQA review.

"I’m not a big time developer. I’m a guy who lives in the neighborhood near Julius’ Castle," Scott told the Planning Commission at the time. "I picked up the building because it had been sitting there and had been falling in disrepair … and has the potential to become a beautiful building again."  

Julius' Castle and Coit Tower in 1961. | Photo: San Francisco History Center/San Francisco Public Library

In September, Friends of Montgomery Street appealed the commission's decision at the Board of Supervisors, which the Board rejected, concluding that "the project qualifies for an exemption under CEQA."

The city subsequently issued a conditional use authorization, but the nonprofit filed suit claiming that officials violated state law because a categorical exemption is "inappropriate" in this instance.

According to the plaintiffs, the former restaurant lacks "necessary public services and facilities," including "adequate vehicular access" and parking. According to Friends of Montgomery Street, "the project would have significant impacts" on the neighborhood. 

Additionally, the suit alleges that the city has allowed for the operation of "a noisy commercial land use" in a residential area.

"Not only would [the] project operation be noisy and create noxious odors, it would create safety hazards and exacerbate local air pollution by substantially increasing vehicle traffic on the narrow residential road that provides the sole vehicular access to the ... site," the complaint reads in part.

Julius' Castle. | Photo: Dennis Jarvis/Flickr

In response, the City Attorney Office said the petitioners's case lacked merit on the grounds "that the historic restaurant, which for decades operated successfully in the same building atop Telegraph Hill, now somehow poses 'unusual circumstances' that preclude San Francisco’s approval."

Via email, City Attorney's office spokesperson John Cote said the matter "is a baseless lawsuit and a classic case of NIMBYism," noting that the proposal to reopen the restaurant in the same building where it formerly operated was green-lit by SF Planning and the Board of Supervisors.

"The project does not propose to expand the building, and it includes numerous conditions designed to minimize any inconvenience to neighbors," said Cote." The requirements for approval were diligently followed here. We look forward to the court affirming that."

The trial date — a hearing before a judge with no jury — is expected to be heard November 16 at the court’s request.

We've reached out to the law firm representing the petitioners for comment but have not heard back as of press time. 

The restaurant, which opened in 1924, was built by restaurateur Julius Roz, an Italian immigrant. A popular destination for celebrities and politicians for decades, Found SF reports that Montgomery Street was once so narrow that Roz installed a turntable in 1931 to make it easier for cars to turn around. 

Used as an exterior filming location for the 1951 thriller "The House on Telegraph Hill," the restaurant was granted landmark status in 1980.

21 minutes ago
San Francisco Ingleside Mission Terrace Sunnyside

City College site ramps up mass vaccinations with hundreds per day, hoping to reach 3,000 per day

While San Francisco and other cities around the country are facing shortages of vaccine supply compared with demand, the process of getting vaccines into arms quickly and efficiently continues to be honed in the city with the opening of the first of three mass-vaccination sites, at the main campus of City College. Read More

Jan 22, 2021
San Francisco Twin Peaks

SFMTA proposes reopening most of Twin Peaks to vehicle access

SFMTA staff are recommending reopening more than half of Twin Peaks to cars, despite broad public embracement of the park for non-vehicle recreation. Read More

Jan 19, 2021
San Francisco Chinatown

$1.9 Million Chinatown relief measure passes Board of Supervisors

The Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a relief measure that would pay ailing Chinatown restaurants nearly $2 million to serve up meals for their neighbors in need. Read More

Jan 19, 2021
San Francisco Tenderloin

The Tenderloin used to have a bar where a woman was convalescing in a bed behind a curtain in back

An autobiographical essay titled "The Hard Crowd" by novelist Rachel Kushner, published in last week's New Yorker, offers some vivid snapshots of several long-gone Tenderloin bars, including one with a convalescing person in a bed in back. Read More