El Paso

El Paso Deputies Thwart Potential Tragedy in Cimarron Hills, Seize Drugs and Unmarked Firearms

AI Assisted Icon
Published on September 26, 2025
El Paso Deputies Thwart Potential Tragedy in Cimarron Hills, Seize Drugs and Unmarked FirearmsSource: El Paso County Sheriff’s Office

In the early hours of last Tuesday morning, El Paso County Sheriff's Office deputies intervened in what could have been an unnoticed episode in Cimarron Hills had they not been observant. They spotted a Chevrolet truck, stagnant in a traffic lane, hauling another vehicle, and took action. What seemed like a routine check swiftly escalated as the deputies discovered the occupants apparently unconscious and in possession of a cache of contraband. The story, detailed by the El Paso County Sheriff's Office, paints a picture of the scourge of drugs and illegal firearms present in modern urban environments.

Upon examining the vehicle, which had idled near Meadowbrook Parkway and Woolsey Heights, deputies found Allison Ciaramitaro, 39, behind the wheel, and James Neeley, 42, as her companion. Their initial unresponsiveness raised suspicions, and perhaps rightly so. Inside, the deputies found not just syringes brazenly lying around but an armamentarium that included a loaded 9mm pistol, a short-barreled 9mm rifle without identifying markings, and an assortment of narcotics, methamphetamine, and fentanyl, among them, as well as burglary tools. Neeley's criminal record, featuring a conviction for Aggravated Robbery, complicated his predicament with a fresh lineup of charges, including being a Special Offender and Possession of Weapons by a Previous Offender.

The gravity of their findings was not lost on Sheriff Joseph Roybal, who remarked, "This case highlights the dangers our deputies face daily when confronting drugs and illegal firearms in our community." He continued, acknowledging the valor required to navigate such hazards, "Thanks to their quick actions, dangerous narcotics and untraceable weapons were taken off the streets," as per the El Paso County Sheriff's Office. These comments underscore an ongoing tension between law enforcement efforts and legislative challenges. Roybal's frustration was palpable as he lamented how weak laws in Colorado continue to allow dangerous and prolific criminals to cycle through the system, corrupting our communities and preying on the vulnerable.