Boston

Essex Landing Developers Sue Town of Saugus and Town Manager for Alleged "Arbitrary and Discriminatory" Treatment

AI Assisted Icon
Published on September 12, 2025
Essex Landing Developers Sue Town of Saugus and Town Manager for Alleged "Arbitrary and Discriminatory" TreatmentSource: Google Street View

In an unfolding legal drama, TB Holdings LLC, the developers behind Essex Landing and the custodians of the beloved orange dinosaur in Saugus, have filed a lawsuit against the Town of Saugus and Town Manager Scott Crabtree. According to Boston.com, the developers are claiming "arbitrary and discriminatory" treatment by the town manager, alleging that he exerted pressure on them to make a $200,000 donation for the project's advancement.

The heart of the litigation lies in the accusation of pressure from Crabtree regarding a 'grant' to the town's parks and recreation, a payment the developers believed was pivotal considering they had already sunk $18 million into the project. The lawsuit, which details the strained communications between TB Holdings and Crabtree, has resulted in accusations of constitutional violations on the part of the town. However, despite filing the complaint on Aug. 21, the company insists that their plans for the assisted living facility and other residential units are still progressing, albeit without a set timeline, as Boston.com reported.

Diving deeper into the lawsuit specifics obtained from ItemLive, the developer highlights multiple counts of alleged rights violations, including the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments and a claim under the Fair Housing Act. The lawsuit also suggests that despite the $200,000 payment, for which the developer states there was no obligation, regulations or condition, Crabtree and the town continued to thwart the development efforts.

The legal complaint casts a spotlight on the complex interplay between local governance and property development, representing a multimillion-dollar allegation against a town official. In the lawsuit, TB Holdings allegedly paid the sum without seeing any desirable change in the process, an event where while aggression is not the intent, the developers contend they observe their constitutional rights being compromised. Among the concerns listed, a violation of the Massachusetts Public Records Law is speculated, adding another layer to the ongoing dispute.

The complexity of the case is further underlined by the multiple counts addressed in the legal documents, which range from coercion to interference with rights protected by the Fair Housing Act, as TB Holdings accuses the defendants of preventing them from exercising their rights in connection to the development of Units 4 and 5 into an assisted living facility. In the charges, TB Holdings does not mince words, demanding the court hold the defendants liable for the alleged violations, as noted in the ItemLive article.