Trevor Story's rough start to 2026 has pushed the Boston Red Sox into an early season crossroads. The veteran shortstop is hitting just .200 with a .520 OPS, piling up strikeouts and high-profile mistakes in the field. With Boston stuck at 17-23, the leash on a struggling veteran might not stay long.
According to a recent report from Boston.com, one of the simpler solutions on the table is to shift Story to second base and give 23-year-old Marcelo Mayer the everyday job at shortstop. That same report outlines far harsher possibilities, from a salary-dump trade to designating Story for assignment, moves that would clear a roster spot but come with financial and public-relations fallout. All of it is tangled up in the roughly $50 million still owed on Story's contract, which makes any clean breakup a tricky proposition.
Where the club stands
"I think it's just a matter of time before I get it right," Story told Peter Abraham of The Boston Globe, conceding that the mental grind is part of the slump. Abraham's recap also highlighted Story's misplay at Fenway that opened the door to two runs in a 4-1 Rays win, a moment the home crowd made sure he heard. Story's acknowledgement that there is no magic mechanical fix captures the unease inside a clubhouse that counted on him as a stabilizing veteran.
Local commentators have been busy weighing how aggressive the front office should be, with NBC Sports Boston outlining the realistic paths ahead. General manager Craig Breslow can ride out the contract and preserve roster continuity, pursue a trade that sheds salary while likely bringing back little talent, or eat the money and designate Story for assignment to create an opening. None of those choices guarantees an immediate upgrade on the field, which helps explain why the club has moved cautiously so far.
Numbers say why
The underlying metrics do not offer much comfort. Statcast data on Baseball Savant show Story with 155 at-bats, 55 strikeouts and only seven walks this season, producing a .200/.236/.284 line and that .520 OPS. He has also committed five errors, which has taken a visible toll on Boston's run prevention. Those numbers are a big reason why a benching or position switch has become a serious topic inside the organization.
Marcelo Mayer, the 23-year-old infielder viewed as the future of the Boston infield, represents the upside play if the Sox slide Story off shortstop. Scouting reports from outlets such as Baseball America have praised Mayer's bat speed and defensive ability, suggesting he can grow into the shortstop role with consistent reps. Handing him the position for an extended stretch would let Boston test its internal depth and see whether a younger core can outperform a veteran whose production has dipped.
What the Red Sox do next will depend heavily on two variables: whether Story can rediscover the late-2025 surge that rescued his season, and whether Mayer is ready to handle shortstop without a major drop-off. The Globe and other local outlets have pointed out that Story has a history of eventually working his way out of prolonged slumps, but with the current roster underachieving, the margin for error is slim. For now, Boston appears content to keep weighing its options and hoping Story's turnaround arrives before the Fenway patience meter hits empty.
_(cropped).jpg){kind=link}