Prosecutors say an Arnold man already facing an embezzlement case did not stay out of trouble for long. Brett A. Fisher, previously free on bond, was arrested after authorities say he stole from another employer while managing the South Lindbergh America's Incredible Pizza Company. Investigators allege Fisher kept cash deposits he was supposed to take to the bank. He is now back behind bars on a $100,000 cash-only bond while the new felony case moves through court.
What prosecutors allege
According to FOX2, the St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office has charged Fisher with stealing $25,000 or more after investigators connected roughly $63,171.51 in missing deposits to him. Police say he diverted cash that should have been deposited, and a separate incident at the South Lindbergh pizza location was tied to $29,330.11 in allegedly missing funds.
Video evidence and an admission
Investigators reviewed a probable cause statement that, according to law-enforcement accounts, describes security cameras recording Fisher taking money from a safe and then leaving the restaurant with the cash. The same statement says Fisher admitted to taking money and told detectives he had a gambling problem.
Bond and court process
Authorities say Fisher had been out on bond in a related case when detectives uncovered the new alleged theft, prompting prosecutors to file a fresh felony charge. Prosecutors obtained a $100,000 cash-only bond, and the case was filed in Clayton, where future hearings and motions will be scheduled.
Why it matters locally
Cash-heavy spots like restaurants and arcades live and die by daily deposits and reconciliation. Prosecutors say those routine financial controls helped flag the discrepancies that ultimately triggered the investigation. For local business owners, the case serves as a pointed reminder that surveillance, clear deposit procedures and regular audits can be crucial tools for catching internal losses early.
What's next
Per FOX2, Fisher faces a felony count of stealing $25,000 or more, allegations that prosecutors will still have to prove in court. The St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office will move the case forward, and upcoming hearings and any potential resolutions will be detailed in court records.
