The lights are going out again at Park Tavern. The sprawling North Beach restaurant that looks out over Washington Square will serve its final meals later this month, owner James Nicholas confirmed, bringing an abrupt end to a short-lived comeback that brought star chef Jonathan Waxman back into the fold in 2024. Nicholas said the dining room will stay open for roughly two more weeks so regulars and neighbors can squeeze in a last visit.
Nicholas broke the news yesterday on Instagram, calling the restaurant a fixture of the city’s food scene. He wrote that “Park Tavern has been an important part of San Francisco's dining community for nearly two decades,” according to the San Francisco Chronicle. In the post, he thanked guests, employees and nearby businesses, and invited the community to come help close things out on a high note.
A Rocky Comeback
Park Tavern first opened in 2011 and quickly became a marquee North Beach address, earning a James Beard Award semifinalist nod for best new restaurant in 2012, according to Eater SF. The good times did not exactly roll in a straight line. The restaurant closed and reopened multiple times during the pandemic, then went dark again after an eviction dispute in December 2023, SFGATE reported.
After that shutdown, Nicholas signed a new lease and brought Park Tavern back in 2024 with Jonathan Waxman overseeing the menu, a comeback chronicled in Hoodline coverage of its revamped reopening. For longtime fans, it looked like the latest chapter might finally stick.
Legal Background
The 2023 collapse did not happen quietly. The landlord sued Nicholas, alleging more than $500,000 in unpaid rent, according to SFGATE. That court fight helped set the stage for the December 2023 closure, followed by the later relaunch under the new agreement.
Critical Response
Even with the high-profile return and Waxman’s name on the menu, the rebooted Park Tavern struggled to live up to its earlier glory. Reviews of the new version pointed to uneven service and hit-or-miss execution, the San Francisco Chronicle reported. Those mixed notices landed on top of the cost pressures, staffing challenges and general headwinds that have been hammering San Francisco restaurants, making it harder for Park Tavern to regain its old footing.
What’s Next for the Space
What comes after Park Tavern at 1652 Stockton St. is anyone’s guess. The landlord listed the property following the earlier dispute, SFGATE reported, and no successor has been announced.
In his farewell message, Nicholas urged diners to treat the remaining days as a sendoff. He asked guests to “raise a glass, share a meal, and celebrate the memories” during the final service window, a last run that is likely to draw North Beach regulars back to Washington Square one more time.
Reservations for the final nights will be limited, and the restaurant plans to share updates on its social channels. After that, North Beach will once again watch a familiar dining room go dark and wait to see what, if anything, takes its place.
-2.webp?w=160&h=400&fit=crop&crop=edges)
