
A $50,000 gift written into a 1952 will is now in a Kentucky appeals fight over who may receive it. Lucille Newmark left the money to create a University of Louisville medical-school scholarship for Black students. The UofL Foundation, which manages the fund, and Attorney General Russell Coleman want that racial restriction removed. Jefferson Circuit Judge Eric Haner said no.
The appeal turns on whether a scholarship designed to last indefinitely can still use an exception in 2025's House Bill 4 for older, privately funded awards. WDRB reported that Coleman and the Foundation asked a judge to drop the race-based requirement, and that Coleman has appealed Haner's refusal. The appeals court has not ruled.
A Will Written At The Edge Of Integration
Newmark died in 1952 and, as WVXU reported, created the scholarship in her will for “colored students” at UofL’s medical school. The bequest was $50,000. Louisville Urban League president Lyndon Pryor has said the university began enrolling Black students in 1951, so the gift arrived almost as soon as that door opened.
Pryor says the Foundation wants to keep the money without honoring the gift's intent. Coleman says his office is working with the Foundation “to ensure compliance with state law and promote fair access for Kentucky students,” and that the work includes ending what he calls preferential treatment under House Bill 4.
The Foundation has said the money cannot legally be distributed while the race requirement remains. Coleman has also argued the restriction is unlikely to be used and the money may sit unspent. Keith Sherman, speaking for the Foundation, said it wants to respect donor intent and still get scholarship dollars to the students they were meant to reach.
An Exception That Ends When The Corpus Does
House Bill 4 bars identity-based criteria in public-university programs, then leaves a narrower exit. The bill text says restrictions requiring an institution to consider an applicant’s religion, race, sex, color or national origin may continue until the balance of the corpus is exhausted. Haner cited that exception for certain privately funded scholarships created before the law took effect.
Coleman’s office says Newmark’s fund does not qualify because it is a permanent endowment and only earnings are spent. In that reading, a fund built to last never reaches the cutoff the statute uses. He consented to the Foundation’s petition in Jefferson Circuit Court and has cited the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2023 decision against race-conscious college admissions.
The Louisville Urban League and the Falls City Medical Society answer that Newmark’s will did not require the principal to be preserved, so the Foundation could spend the fund down. They also argue the Supreme Court case concerned admissions, not private gifts, and that this scholarship pays only after a student has already been admitted. On Nov. 16 they filed motions to submit briefs supporting Haner’s ruling. The appeals court has not ruled on those motions. Coleman’s office has requested oral argument.
Five Scholarships, Two Judges
The Newmark fund is not the only gift the Foundation took to court. In February 2026 it filed two petitions asking Jefferson County judges to change the rules of five privately funded scholarships designed for women and Black students, WVXU reported.
One judge removed the requirements from four funds originally designed for women. Haner rejected the request on the fund now on appeal. The difference Coleman presses is structural: a fund that can be spent down can age out of the exception, and a fund built to last cannot.
Elsewhere in the state, the choice has sometimes been to stop writing checks. Louisville Public Media reported that other Kentucky universities, including Western Kentucky University, have paused at least one scholarship indefinitely because the original donors would not change criteria reserved for specific identity groups.
A Foundation Next Door To The University
The university is not a party to the Foundation’s lawsuit. LPM reported that separation directly. The Foundation’s bylaws still give the university president and other university officials seats on its board, and Gerry Bradley, who signed a letter to university staff, is a Foundation director.
In that letter, Bradley said courts apply the Supreme Court’s admissions ruling to scholarship administration, and that UofL remains committed to college access and student success. The case caption leaves the university out. The staff letter treats the legal theory as the university’s problem anyway.
A second review is running on a different clock. UofL has said federal officials are examining some university scholarships and other benefits that consider race or gender. A spokesperson said that review began in 2025 and offered no further details. It is not this appeal, and it is not a decision on Newmark’s will.
What Students Hear While The Briefs Sit
Ezra Foote, who chairs the College Republicans chapter at UofL, supports House Bill 4 and argues the scholarship violates the 14th Amendment’s equal-protection clause. Ricky Jones, a professor of Pan-African studies who taught Porter Scholars during 29 years at the university, says UofL’s approach to following the law is inconsistent. Porter Scholars began as a Black-exclusive program. Its recipients are now 18% Black.
Pryor wants the appeals court to reject Coleman’s appeal and leave Haner’s ruling in place. While that request is pending, the practical question is whether a medical student who matches Newmark’s terms can be paid from the fund at all. The Foundation says distribution is legally blocked so long as the restriction stands. The groups defending the will say the restriction is what the donor required.
Coleman has asked for oral argument. Until the appeals court answers, Haner’s reading of the exhaustion clause is the ruling on the books, and the Foundation’s position is that the checks stay unwritten. A gift made the year after UofL began enrolling Black students, by Pryor’s account, is being asked to outlive the terms that made it a gift.









