
A Jeffersonville murder case that has already churned through three separate trials is now in front of the Indiana Supreme Court, where justices first have to decide whether they will even take up the appeal. Christian White, convicted of murder by a third jury after his first trial ended in a mistrial, argues through his legal team that he should never have faced that third trial at all, citing the Fifth Amendment's protection against double jeopardy.
A Case That Went Through Three Juries
According to WHAS11, White's first trial ended in a mistrial because of a lack of jurors, forcing the case to be retried. During his second trial, he was convicted of unlawful possession of a firearm, but that proceeding did not resolve the murder charge itself. It took a third jury to finally convict White of murder, a path his attorneys say violated his constitutional protections against being tried repeatedly for the same offense.
White is accused of holding two women and a two-year-old hostage in Jeffersonville, and the station reports he was allegedly on the run after shooting and killing Marcus Suggs, a man. Those underlying allegations have not been resolved through the appellate record reviewed for this story, and the precise trial history beyond what has been reported remains limited to what the station and court filings describe.
Double Jeopardy at the Center of the Appeal
White's legal team argued that he should not have faced another murder trial after the mistrial and subsequent firearm conviction, contending the repeated proceedings amounted to the state getting multiple bites at a conviction. The state, for its part, said the trials were disorganized from the beginning, pushing back on the notion that the repeated proceedings were an improper attempt to secure a conviction.
A separate excerpt from an Indiana Court of Appeals opinion identifies a Christian Q. White as appealing a case in which the question was whether the state's decision to retry him twice more violated the Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment, according to a document posted by public.courts.in.gov. The opinion concludes, '[w]e affirm.'
Justices Have Not Yet Decided Whether to Take the Case
The Indiana Supreme Court is now considering whether White's second and third trials were invalid because of double jeopardy, but justices have made clear they have a preliminary step to clear first. The court said it will first decide whether to grant a transfer on the case before reaching any decision on the substance of the double jeopardy claim, and justices did not decide that transfer question during Tuesday's proceedings.
The broader constitutional question—whether White's third trial should have happened at all—was addressed by the Indiana Court of Appeals in a June 2, 2026 opinion, which affirmed his convictions; the question may remain pending before the Indiana Supreme Court. Indiana law governing standards of proof and bars to prosecution, including protections against being tried twice for the same conduct, is laid out under IC 35-41, Chapter 4, though the excerpt available does not offer a full explanation of how those statutory provisions apply to White's specific circumstances.
Until the justices rule on whether to grant transfer, White's murder conviction from the third trial stands. The case continues to work its way through Indiana's appellate system.









