
When the Christmas blizzard of 2022 buried Western New York, a McDonald's at Sheridan Drive and Sweet Home Road in Amherst became an unlikely shelter after manager Kristin Kosha invited in anyone who needed a warm place to ride out the storm. Now that night of strangers huddled together has become a documentary short, The Buffalo Miracle, directed by Oscar winner Ben Proudfoot.
The shelter unfolded amid conditions that overwhelmed ordinary travel and emergency response. New York’s independent review says Erie County endured 37 consecutive hours of blizzard-like conditions, with zero visibility, extreme cold and more than 80,000 households without power at the storm’s height. State agencies carried out more than 650 rescues in Western New York, while local officials rescued hundreds more, the state review found. Those figures place the Amherst restaurant’s refuge within a regionwide emergency, not an isolated snowbound inconvenience.
How the Story Became a Film
The Buffalo News reported that about 50 people sheltered at the McDonald's during the blizzard. When Proudfoot visited the restaurant with Kosha more than a year later, he spotted a cardboard cutout of Allen inside, according to the same account.
Proudfoot tracked down people who had been at the restaurant during the storm.
The Faces Inside the Storm
The documentary focuses on the people who sought refuge at the McDonald's during the blizzard, weaving together their individual stories from that night. Among them are Maria Alessia Bessing and Lyndon Hayles. The film also features Tan and Lili Zhao, the Bessing family, Paache Spikes-Redding, and Amherst police officers Thomas M. Brown and Derek Westbrook. According to Media Play News, the film blends firsthand accounts from blizzard survivors with hand-drawn animation.
The McDonald’s was not the only improvised refuge. During the same storm, Buffalo barber Craig Elston opened C&C Cutz to roughly 50 people, while stranded shoppers took shelter at a Target as snow buried its parking lot, Fox Weather reported. Erie County’s health department later described localized mutual-aid responses as strong and organically managed, and called for closer connections with informal volunteer groups. The parallel shows how businesses and residents helped people find shelter as roads and emergency services were strained.
Proudfoot won Oscars for the 2022 short The Queen of Basketball and The Last Repair Shop, according to Gold Derby's account of his career.
A Moved Crowd at Telluride
The Buffalo Miracle premiered at the Telluride Film Festival in September. The documentary short debuted on HBO and HBO Max on Nov. 24.
The improvised shelter also sits against a larger debate over preparedness. New York commissioned an independent review that produced 12 recommendations spanning communications, emergency technology, local capacity and coordination, including a blizzard-specific planning annex and more regional exercises, the state said. Erie County’s health department separately urged closer collaboration with community groups and mutual-aid leaders in its after-action review. The film’s intimate story echoes a question officials raised afterward: how to connect spontaneous neighbor-to-neighbor help with formal emergency systems.
For a region that still remembers the deadly 2022 storm, the film offers a record of the strangers who looked out for one another while the snow fell.









