
Little Sicily's Pizza, the family-run pizzeria that has anchored Brice Road on Columbus's east side since 1975, is closing its doors for the entire month of December for renovations. The shop remains open through December 1, and staff hope to be back serving pies by January if the work stays on schedule.
The closure was first reported by 614NOW, which described Little Sicily's as a longtime family-run pizzeria on the east side of Columbus, located at 2965 Brice Road. According to the outlet, an employee said the restaurant expects to resume operations in January 2027 if the renovations go according to plan. The specific plans for the pizzeria's facelift had not been announced at the time of the report, the outlet noted.
A Fixture of Brice Since the Mid-70s
Little Sicily's has built its reputation over five decades in Brice, the small community tucked into Columbus's east side. The shop is known for its “pizza worth the drive” reputation, per the same 614NOW account, a nod to loyal customers willing to cross town for a slice. That tagline has roots going back years: a 2013 review from CMH Gourmand noted that “the tagline on the menu is 'The Pizza Worth The Drive,'” and called Little Sicily's an institution in Brice since 1975.
That same 2013 review painted a picture of a neighborhood staple where the regulars were on a first-name basis with the staff. “All of the customers were long time regulars who the servers knew by name,” the CMH Gourmand review observed. The restaurant's longstanding ties to the community were echoed again in a 2021 614NOW review, which similarly described Little Sicily's as a family-owned restaurant that has been part of the village of Brice since 1975.
What Diners Will Miss During the Closure
Part of the restaurant's charm, per 614NOW's report, comes from its unpretentious setup: a relaxed dining room and a carryout window, paired with vintage sports decor and an open view of the kitchen and ovens where the pizzas are made. Those details have made Little Sicily's a draw for diners who want to watch their pie come together before it hits the table.
For now, the plans for what exactly the renovation will change remain unclear, with 614NOW reporting that the specifics of the facelift are unknown. Customers on Columbus's east side will have to wait out December before finding out what's new when the doors reopen, tentatively, come January.









