Southwest Florida/ Politics & Govt

Captiva Panel Warns County Plan Overhaul Could Allow Unlimited Number of Hotels

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Captiva Panel Warns County Plan Overhaul Could Allow Unlimited Number of Hotels2115 Second St #207 — County Reviewing Community Plan Changes
Google Street View

The fight to save Captiva's decades-old local development rules is far from over, according to leaders of the Captiva Community Panel, who used a meeting Tuesday to warn residents that a Lee County proposal to eliminate the island's community plan remains alive even after commissioners paused it in September. Panel president David Mintz told members that one additional commission vote is needed to stop the elimination.

Mintz's update came at a Captiva Community Panel meeting, where he walked members through what the proposed overhaul would and would not preserve, according to the Sanibel-Captiva Islander. The panel, formed in 2000-01, created Chapter 23 of the county's comprehensive plan and land development code, which the Islander reports has long governed Captiva's development and land use through a set of long-term goals, objectives, policies and codes specific to the island.

At issue is a broader Lee County effort that began last spring, when commissioners asked staff to review 17 community plans countywide to find efficiencies, duplications and confusing provisions, according to the Captiva Sanibel Islander. Staff presented their recommendations on Aug. 25, and the Lee County Local Planning Agency subsequently voted 4-2 to recommend the changes for adoption, as reported by Gulfshore Business.

What Mintz Says the Proposal Would Strip Away

Mintz told the panel the proposal, per his reading, would eliminate the Captiva community plan and Chapter 23 land development code outright, and he said that elimination could open the door to completely changing the island. Among the specific changes he cited: the proposal would eliminate requirements to reduce minimum lot size, hotel density and building height, and would let Lee County rezone any Captiva property as a planned development.

Mintz also said the current code caps hotel or condominium heights at 90 feet above base flood elevation, while the proposal would allow heights up to 75 feet but with no numerical limit on the number of hotels — a tradeoff he framed as a net loss of protection. He said the proposal would further eliminate the requirement to maintain and enforce Captiva's historic development plan, drop strict requirements on variances and deviations, and remove central sewer sizing tied to Captiva's development pattern.

On environmental protections, Mintz said the Captiva Plan currently enforces shoreline protection to the greatest extent possible, while proposed wording would only require mangroves to maintain adequate protection. He added that the proposed plan does not mention Blind Pass at all, and that a proposed replacement would instead authorize maintenance of channels and passes only where economically feasible. Mintz also said the proposal would eliminate public participation and public information meetings specific to Captiva plans, which he characterized as swapping individualized community plans for a one-size-fits-all countywide approach.

County Staff Describe a Different Goal

Lee County planning manager Brandon Dunn has described the intent differently, telling Gulfshore Business the goal is to make the plan clearer and simpler without changing how much development is allowed. County staff likewise said the proposed amendment would not change current density or intensity requirements, according to the same report — a characterization that conflicts with the specific rollbacks Mintz described to the panel. The dossier does not resolve that dispute, and both the county's and Mintz's framings are described here as each side presented them.

The proposal hit a procedural roadblock in September, when the Lee County Board of County Commissioners voted to pause the amendments and send them back to staff, canceling a scheduled Oct. 7 hearing, the Pine Island Eagle reported. Commissioners directed staff to develop a revised timeline and conduct community outreach before bringing the changes back. Mintz told the panel he remains unaware of county staff returning with any new timetable or proposal since that pause.

A Coalition Forms Across Lee County Communities

The pushback against the broader overhaul has spread well beyond Captiva. The Captiva Civic Association has said the island's plan and code provisions limit density and building heights, prevent the subdivision of properties, limit outdoor lighting and sign pollution, and protect beaches, mangrove fringe and waterways, per the same Pine Island Eagle account. Those concerns helped drive formation of the Lee Communities Coalition, created by area civic groups spearheaded by the Greater Pine Island Civic Association, and the Captiva Community Panel has since joined that coalition.

Mintz told members the coalition has hired an attorney and public relations help, meets regularly with county commissioners, and is now preparing bylaws and agreements to formalize its structure, with plans to submit documents containing more detail. Panel member Linda Laird asked whether the coalition needed particular skill sets from volunteers and encouraged members to put the island's skills to use. It isn't the first time Captiva groups have organized around threats to local height and density rules — in July 2023, a coalition of island civic and conservation organizations, including the Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation, the “Ding” Darling Wildlife Society and the Council of Homeowners Associations at South Seas, moved to hire legal representation to protect Captiva's existing restrictions, according to the Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation.

The Vote Count Mintz Says Matters Most

Mintz told the panel he said one additional commission vote is needed to stop the elimination. He noted that Commissioner Kevin Ruane has publicly stated he will not support eliminating the Captiva Plan, and Mintz said he hoped new commissioners starting this week — a group that includes District 5 Commissioner Amanda Cochrane — would help tip the balance against the proposal. Whether a revised version of the amendments returns to the commission, and on what timeline, had not been established as of the panel's meeting.