Southwest Florida/ Crime & Emergencies

Fort Myers Beach Magistrate Slaps Two Pool Owners With $82K and $17.9K Fines

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Fort Myers Beach Magistrate Slaps Two Pool Owners With $82K and $17.9K Fines132 Andre Mar Dr. — Site of $82,000 Pool Fine
Google Street View

A Fort Myers Beach magistrate handed down two steep fines this week over pool code violations, with one property owner on the hook for $82,000 and another facing a $17,900 penalty. Both pools sat out of compliance for more than 100 days before the town's code enforcement process even began, according to Beach Talk Radio News.

Fort Myers Beach Town Magistrate Monica Schmucker fined the owners of two properties for separate pool code violations, per the same outlet's report by Ed Ryan. The larger fine stems from a Wednesday hearing concerning a property at 132 Andre Mar, where the pool has developed a growing yellow substance. The report notes the property owners did not attend the hearing to argue their case, and the $82,000 fine will keep accruing as long as the pool remains in violation.

A Second Property Faces Months of Noncompliance

The owners of a property at 5850 Estero Boulevard received a separate $17,900 fine after their pool was found out of compliance for 114 days, the outlet reported. The same hearing also included property owners cited for work completed without permits, and Schmucker is set to issue orders in those cases within 15 days, according to Beach Talk Radio News.

These are not the first steep pool-related fines to come out of Fort Myers Beach's code enforcement process this year. In a separate case involving a pool at 155 Hibiscus, a special magistrate ordered daily $250 fines and authorized the town to secure the partially fenced pool, according to citizenportal.ai. The town had sought those daily fines for each day the property remained out of compliance after a Jan. 1, 2026 order, per that report.

Other Lee County Properties Have Faced Similar Penalties

A comparable case at 151 Miramar Street shows how quickly these fines can add up. A magistrate found the property's owners noncompliant with a Jan. 27, 2026 enforcement order and imposed fines of $250 per day, citizenportal.ai reported. By Sept. 1, 2026, the town had calculated roughly $39,000 in accrued fines covering 156 days of noncompliance in that case.

Florida law sets the ceiling for how high these penalties can climb. Under Chapter 162 of the 2026 Florida Statutes, fines may not exceed $1,000 per day per violation for a first offense, $5,000 per day for a repeat violation, and up to $15,000 per violation if a board or special magistrate finds the violation irreparable or irreversible in nature.

Who Is Monica Schmucker

Schmucker has held the special magistrate role since January 2024, when the Fort Myers Beach Town Council unanimously approved her appointment. She replaced Myrnabelle Roche, who had resigned the prior year, and at the time of her appointment was a partner in the law firm of Schmucker & Lavy, according to fortmyersbeachtalk.com's original report on the appointment.