Midlands/ Real Estate & Development

Chapin Sewer Freeze Sparks Federal Lawsuit From Stanley Martin Homes, Slice Family

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Chapin Sewer Freeze Sparks Federal Lawsuit From Stanley Martin Homes, Slice FamilyWastewater Treatment Plant
Patrick Federi / Unsplash

Stanley Martin Homes and the Slice family have sued the Town of Chapin in federal court, arguing a freeze on new sewer connections has stalled a planned subdivision near Lake Murray and broken a decade-old development agreement. The lawsuit, filed Oct. 16, targets the town, Mayor Bill Mitchell and utility director David Patton, and claims the freeze was never approved through a public hearing or a vote of the town council.

A Development Stuck Behind a Locked Gate

According to The State, Chapin entered a sewer-service agreement in 2015 with Essex Land Development for the Chapin Place subdivision, a project planned just north of Lake Murray in a town of roughly 2,000 people. That agreement and the underlying site eventually passed to Stanley Martin Homes, which built its own sewer infrastructure for the project expecting credited taps worth $937,000 in return.

The lawsuit says Stanley Martin's predecessor had built and conveyed off-site sewer infrastructure to the town in exchange for 250 sewer tap credits across the development's initial and future phases. The town has acknowledged that 31 of those credited taps are still owed to Chapin Place, the report notes, and the lawsuit says Chapin had previously expressed willingness to issue up to 153 additional taps before the freeze took hold.

Caught in the same bottleneck is a 10.5-acre Lexington County property owned by the Slice family — Thomas, Ruby and Michael Scott Slice — which sits within Chapin's sewer service area. The family agreed in 2025 to sell the land to Stanley Martin for new development, but the suit says the tract requires 77 taps under its contract with the builder, taps the freeze now makes impossible to obtain.

Plaintiffs Say the Freeze Skipped Required Steps

The complaint alleges the sewer-connection freeze amounted to an illegal government decision made without due process, imposed without notice, a public hearing or town council action required under South Carolina law and town ordinances. Plaintiffs allege Mayor Mitchell imposed the freeze unilaterally, establishing what the suit calls an illegal de facto moratorium on residential development in and around Chapin.

Stanley Martin says the freeze frustrated its infrastructure investment and breached its contract with the town, per the same account. The plaintiffs go further, arguing that capacity concerns raised by the town are pretext for what they describe as the mayor's personal anti-growth political agenda, and that Chapin is obligated to issue sewer taps to anyone within its designated sewer service area.

The lawsuit also raises a records dispute: the plaintiffs say that when they sought documents about the freeze, the town asked them to pay $4,000 and provide a driver's license, a demand they argue conflicts with South Carolina's open records laws. As evidence of what plaintiffs' predecessor was told, the article notes a Chapin town engineer informed Stanley Martin in 2022 that the sewer pump near Chapin Place could handle 545 additional homes.

Town Points to a Treatment Plant Years From Done

Chapin's defense centers on capacity. The town says its sewer system is nearing its limits and that new connections will remain limited until it completes a $42 million wastewater treatment plant upgrade that could take up to 10 years, The State reports. Mayor Mitchell has separately said the freeze will remain in place until Chapin can improve and expand its wastewater facilities, according to an earlier report from thestate.com.

A separate account from The Post and Courier says Mitchell froze permits for new developments seeking access to Chapin's treatment system after taking office in November 2025, then extended that freeze to cover any development with more than nine homes.

Chapin town attorney Ryan Hicks filed a motion to dismiss on Nov. 13, arguing the complaint does not plausibly allege a protected activity interest in the additional sewer taps and service commitments the plaintiffs are seeking, nor does it allege the violation of a clearly established constitutional right by any defendant. Hicks has asked the federal court to dismiss the complaint, while leaving plaintiffs free to pursue their South Carolina law claims in state court.

A Second Sewer Fight Already Underway

Chapin's capacity dispute is not new. The town is already a party to a separate lawsuit filed by Lexington County on Aug. 24 over sewer access for a planned 600-home Brighton development, located at a former county technology and business park near Interstate 26, Post and Courier reporting shows. The county argues a signed 2015 contract requires Chapin to provide connections for that project, and reports differ on the contract's exact terms — thestate.com describes it as providing the equivalent of 667 sewer taps, while Post and Courier describes it as requiring 667 water taps tied to the town's water treatment plant.

Post and Courier also reports that the 2015 agreement required Chapin to expand its sewer capacity within 24 months if it lacked the capacity to deliver the promised taps. Lexington County has asked the court to either enforce that contract or order Chapin to pay the business park's $20.4 million purchase price, plus interest, attorney fees and costs.

In the Stanley Martin and Slice family case, the lawsuit asserts claims for breach of contract, deprivation of property without due process or just compensation, a Freedom of Information Act violation and civil conspiracy. It asks the court to order Chapin's utility director to issue the sewer taps the plaintiffs say they are owed, and it seeks damages and attorneys' fees. The plaintiffs are represented by Dylan Glick of Columbia, Carter Massingill of Greenville and Ronald Tate of Greenville, having filed the case in federal court to redress what they describe as a deprivation of constitutional rights under color of state law.