Miami/ Politics & Govt

District 39 Voter Sues DeSantis Over Uncalled Senate Election

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
District 39 Voter Sues DeSantis Over Uncalled Senate ElectionFlorida Supreme Court — Court Where Election Petition Filed
Google Street View

A voter in Florida Senate District 39 wants the state Supreme Court to order Gov. Ron DeSantis to call a special election for the seat Bryan Ávila left empty.

Yahoo reported that Alejandro Peñuela filed a petition for a writ of mandamus on Nov. 17, asking the court to order the governor to perform that duty. Ávila, the lieutenant governor-elect, resigned effective Aug. 25 to run for that office alongside now Gov.-elect Byron Donalds. The petition asks for an election as soon as possible. It does not propose specific dates.

An Empty Chair Headed Toward Session

The petition says the seat has been vacant for almost three months without the governor calling a special election, the Miami Herald reported. The district covers Hialeah, Doral, Miami Lakes, Sweetwater and Medley, and was expected to head into the 2027 legislative session without a state senator.

The filing also calls the wait the longest known in Florida history. And it says, "This is the tenth vacancy over which voters have had to go to court to force the Governor to call an election."

A Duty Without a Stopwatch

When a special election is required to fill a legislative vacancy, Florida Statutes section 100.111 says the governor, after consulting the secretary of state, shall fix the dates of the special primary and the special election. Those dates must be specific days certain, with at least two weeks between the elections.

A Florida attorney general opinion says the governor has a mandatory duty to call a special election when a regular legislative session will be held before the next general election. The provisions describe who sets the dates and how far apart they must fall. They do not, in the text those sources supply, start a numbered countdown on the day a senator resigns.

Sen. Tina Polsky proposed to add one. Her bill would have forced the governor to set dates within 14 days of a vacancy and let voters petition a circuit court if he did not, Florida Politics reported. Asked about the call for this seat, the Governor's Office told the outlet, "More info on that coming soon."

Candidates, and No Ballot Yet

Two House Republicans have already decided they want the job. Reps. Alex Rizo and David Borrero have announced they intend to run when a special election is called, CBS News Miami reported. The ambition is public. The election is not.

The district's politics are not a mystery on paper. As of July 29, Florida Politics reported, 44.6% of its 234,368 registered voters were Republicans, 21.5% were Democrats, and 33.9% belonged to a third party or to no party. Ávila won his 2024 race against a Democrat with 70% of the vote, the Herald reported. This is an empty chair in a seat the last senator carried by a landslide, not a scramble over a coin-flip district.

Voters Have Sued Over the Calendar Before

The ACLU sued DeSantis in January 2025 over delays in calling elections for a Brevard County Senate seat and a Panhandle House seat. DeSantis set those elections on Jan. 21, 2025, Yahoo reported.

Peñuela's petition asks the Supreme Court for speed and leaves the actual days to the governor. Until those days certain are fixed, District 39 is pointed at a 2027 session with no senator of its own.