Salt Lake City/ Crime & Emergencies

Eagle Mountain Family Sues Sheriff Over Deputy's Encounter With Teacher Later Accused of Assault

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Eagle Mountain Family Sues Sheriff Over Deputy's Encounter With Teacher Later Accused of AssaultSource: An Errant Knight / Wikimedia Commons

A family in Eagle Mountain has sued the Utah County Sheriff's Office, alleging a deputy failed to take basic steps during an encounter with Ricardo Prins, a former charter school teacher later accused of sexually assaulting a student. Prins fled to Brazil before he could be arrested, according to the Utah County Sheriff.

Deputy Found Them Parked on a Dirt Trail

The family's complaint centers on a deputy's encounter with Prins and a student on a dirt trail in Eagle Mountain on Nov. 20, 2024 — exactly two years ago today. In its account of the lawsuit, KUTV reported that the student was wearing her cheerleading uniform and that the pair had been arguing while she cried. The complaint alleges the deputy left without establishing who they were or their relationship.

The complaint quotes the deputy asking, “Not turning physical? You guys aren't going to beat the crap out of each other?” before wishing them a good night and leaving without requesting identification, according to the lawsuit. It says the student and Prins did not volunteer details about their relationship, and that the family has video of the encounter.

The family filed the lawsuit Wednesday in state court, alleging the deputy did not do enough after encountering the pair. Neither Prins nor Rockwell Charter School is named as a defendant.

Charges, a Warning, and a Flight to Brazil

Prins, 41, was a teacher at Rockwell Charter School in Eagle Mountain when prosecutors accused him of sexual relationships with two students. He was ultimately charged with 31 counts, including rape and sodomy charges that carry up to life in prison, per the KUTV report — though other coverage has described the charges as 30 felonies and one misdemeanor, a discrepancy the available records do not resolve. The Utah County Sheriff said Prins fled to his native Brazil before he could be arrested.

The lawsuit also alleges that a Rockwell Charter School principal warned Prins police would be coming for him. Rockwell representative Julie Young said she was told that conversation never happened. Young and fellow representative Kat Mitchell told KUTV the school could not answer many questions about the Prins matter, but confirmed he is no longer employed there. Mitchell took over about a year after the charges were filed and said the change in administration reflected a renewed focus on Rockwell's mission of giving every student a place in the school. Young encouraged prospective families to visit and speak with administrators, saying teachers receive ethics training on interacting with students and students are taught about healthy relationships.

A spokesman for the Utah County Sheriff's Office referred questions to the county attorney, who did not return messages seeking comment. Attorneys for the plaintiffs also declined to comment.

The Uphill Battle to Bring Prins Back

Getting Prins back to Utah to face trial may prove difficult. Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray has said extradition from Brazil looks unlikely because the country's constitution bars extradition of Brazilian-born citizens, and information from Homeland Security and ICE indicated Prins applied as a Brazilian-born citizen, according to KSL. Gray said he was working with the U.S. Attorney's Office on a federal unlawful-flight complaint and still planned to pursue Prins's return through Brazil, and he indicated prosecutors might seek an Interpol Red Notice if Brazil refused to extradite him.

What the treaty says about extradition

The U.S.–Brazil extradition treaty’s Additional Protocol says the countries are not obliged to extradite their nationals. It allows a country to surrender a national only if its constitution and laws permit it, and leaves that decision to its executive authority, according to the United Nations Treaty Series.

A legal analyst cited by KSL said that under a best-case scenario, extradition with a cooperative foreign country could wrap up in weeks to months, but in a worst case it could stretch into years, decades, or never happen at all. The outlet pointed to the case of Nicholas Rossi, whom Utah prosecutors spent more than two years trying to extradite from Scotland while he faced separate rape charges in Utah County and Salt Lake County, as an example of how drawn-out such fights can become.

Prins was a teacher at Rockwell Charter School. For the Eagle Mountain family now suing the sheriff's office, the central question remains whether the deputy's encounter two years ago was a missed chance to stop Prins before he ever left the country.