San Diego/ Politics & Govt

Escondido Councilman Joe Garcia Breaks Uniform Law Again, Loses Seat Anyway

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Escondido Councilman Joe Garcia Breaks Uniform Law Again, Loses Seat Anyway201 N Broadway — Site of Council Service and Reelection
Google Street View

Escondido City Council member Joe Garcia ran his 2026 reelection campaign with the same police-uniform photo that got him in legal trouble four years earlier, and a special counsel has now found that he violated California law all over again. Garcia blurred his badge this time around, but investigators concluded that wasn't enough to fix the problem. He went on to lose his reelection bid anyway.

The finding comes from a special counsel report that, according to inewsource, concluded that even after blurring the badge, appearing in uniform remained a “political activity within the prohibition” of state law. The report found that the likely violation ended only when polls closed on November 3. Garcia, who has served on the Escondido City Council since 2020 and also works as a church pastor and former volunteer chaplain with the Escondido Police Department, did not respond to inewsource's request for comment before publication.

Garcia lost his reelection bid earlier this month to challenger Anthony DiMartino, inewsource reported, closing out a third-term campaign that was shadowed by the same photo controversy that dogged him in 2022.

A Second Run-In With the Same Law

This isn't the first time Garcia has been told his use of the photo crossed a legal line. In 2022, special counsel Christina Cameron ordered him to “immediately remove pictures of himself wearing his police uniform from his campaign website” and stop using them in campaign materials, according to the earlier inewsource investigation. That 2022 inquiry, covered separately by the San Diego Union-Tribune, found that Garcia's use of the photo on his website and in campaign mailers violated both state law and city rules. At the time, Garcia said he had no intent to deceive or violate any laws, rules or policies, and said he was unaware of a prohibition against campaigning in uniform. He also said he would comply with the lawyers' review.

That review didn't stop him from leaning on the image again four years later. The Coast News Group reported that Garcia used the same photo in a campaign mailer sent to residents as he sought a third term, writing that “four years later, Garcia used the same photo in a campaign mailer sent to residents as he sought a third term.” Garcia told the Times-Advocate on October 28 that he had tried to fix the problem, saying, “I made every effort to ensure that the picture in question was in full compliance by blurring portions of the image,” according to the same outlet.

Blurring the Badge Wasn't Enough

Garcia also added a disclaimer beneath the photo on his website and said he thought those changes would bring him into compliance with the law, per inewsource's October 28 report. The special counsel disagreed. The firm Devany, Pate, Morris & Cameron LLP released a 37-page report Wednesday concluding that appearing in uniform remained prohibited political activity despite the blurred badge — the same conclusion inewsource highlighted in its latest report.

The special counsel referred the matter for investigation one week before the election and completed its report after voters had already cast their ballots, according to inewsource's reporting. The report also noted that Garcia did not respond to investigators, the outlet reported.

What the Law Actually Says

The underlying statute at the center of both investigations is California Government Code Section 3206, which states plainly that “no officer or employee of a local agency shall participate in political activities of any kind while in uniform,” according to California Legislative Information. The 2022 investigation had also found that Garcia's use of the photo did not improperly use city resources, since the photo belonged to him personally, the Coast News Group reported at the time.

Garcia has used pictures of himself in a police uniform in campaign material across two election cycles now, each time facing a special counsel finding that the practice broke state law. With his council tenure ending after his loss to DiMartino, the latest report closes out a saga that began with a near-identical finding back in 2022.