
Eugene renters struggling to buy a home of their own may eventually get first dibs on purchasing the building they already live in. On Monday, the Eugene City Council voted 6-2 to direct staff to return with a work plan for a Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act, a policy that would require landlords to notify tenants before selling and give tenant associations a chance to buy the property before it hits the open market.
Council Keeps the Idea Moving Despite Staff Pushback
The vote came after councilors discussed the proposal, known as TOPA, during a work session on Nov. 9 — a 40-minute discussion that ran out of allotted time before councilors could finish, according to Lookout Eugene-Springfield. Five of the council's eight members said that day they wanted to keep the initiative alive, even though City Manager Jenny Haruyama had recommended sticking with existing affordable housing programs and waiting to see whether state lawmakers would take bolder action instead, the outlet reported. Haruyama argued a statewide program would have access to more funding than a city-only effort, according to the seed reporting from the Daily Emerald.
Not everyone on the council wanted to wait. Councilor Matt Keating said he was not interested in holding off, and that he wanted to provide purchase opportunities for residents while simultaneously educating state partners about the work Eugene is already doing. Keating pointed to a visit he made to southeast Eugene with a friend, which left him concerned about how far out of reach homeownership felt for some residents, per the Daily Emerald's reporting.
What TOPA Would Actually Do
Under the policy as described, property owners would have to notify building residents before listing a sale, and tenant associations could make a decision to purchase the property before it goes to the open market. The goals, according to the Daily Emerald, are to keep prices stable, prevent tenant displacement, preserve affordable housing and expand access to homeownership. Amy Cameron, the city's rental housing analyst, said TOPA could improve housing affordability and stability, prevent displacement, mitigate real estate speculation and create pathways to homeownership, the outlet reported.
Councilor Alan Zelenka said Eugene is far behind in providing homeownership opportunities and called TOPA a useful tool toward that goal, arguing an incremental plan would put the city ahead on homeownership and housing concerns. The council had already implemented the first two phases of its renter protections process, and TOPA had been discussed as a possible addition to a third phase.
The Price Tag Worries Some Councilors
Money was the sticking point for several council members. City staff estimated a TOPA program would need roughly $50,000 in city subsidy for each housing unit, Lookout Eugene-Springfield reported, citing a city analyst's account of advocates' estimates. Developing the proposal itself would likely require hiring an outside consultant at an estimated cost of $75,000 to $100,000, a process expected to take six to eight months, with staff estimating it would then take another six to eight months for councilors to hash out a final proposal and another year to a year and a half before it could be implemented, per the same outlet.
Councilor Randy Groves said he was concerned TOPA could divert scarce resources away from affordable housing programs that already have limited capital and are producing good work, and he said he was hesitant to pull funding from efforts that are succeeding. Mayor Kaarin Knudson echoed that worry, saying she did not want limited resources allocated to a program lacking the capital and support needed to actually help people — and that without funding, the policy could end up benefiting higher-income residents while excluding low-income and marginalized residents it was meant to serve. Knudson said she wants the city to use its resources effectively before making major decisions.
Yeh and Housing Providers Weigh Performative Risk
Councilor Jennifer Yeh said she supported TOPA but raised a risk that the program could end up performative, with few residents actually able to use it, and she identified uncertainty about whether there would be sufficient program funding and staffing to make it work. Will Dowdy, Eugene's community development director, said community members tend to view programs without clear funding options as performative, according to the Daily Emerald's account.
Affordable housing providers also raised concerns about scarce local resources and the policy's potential effectiveness, saying they would prefer additional incentives rather than new regulatory policies, Lookout Eugene-Springfield reported. Councilors still have to decide whether any eventual TOPA policy would focus on apartments, low-density housing or affordable housing specifically, the outlet noted.
The Numbers Driving the Debate
The push for a tenant purchase program comes against a backdrop of steep affordability gaps in Eugene. Nearly 60% of Eugene renters are considered cost-burdened, compared with around 26% of homeowners, while roughly 48% of the city's population owns their home, according to the Daily Emerald's reporting on 2025 Eugene housing statistics. Separately, about 57% of Eugene renter households were considered cost-burdened based on 2024 five-year American Community Survey estimates cited in council documents, according to Daily Tidings. That outlet also reported that from 2012 to 2024, median household income in the city rose 80%, while single-family home prices climbed 139%.
A one-pager from the National Low Income Housing Coalition reported that 78% of extremely low-income renters in Eugene pay more than half their monthly income on rent. The group also noted that a summary of Springfield-Eugene Tenant Association hotline calls from January through November 2025 recorded more than 700 calls about termination notices, with at least a third tied to nonpayment of rent.
Resident Lyndsie Leech Sees Ownership as a Path Out of Poverty
For Eugene resident Lyndsie Leech, the debate is personal. Leech said homeownership was her primary goal, describing buying property as one of the top avenues for building wealth and overcoming poverty, according to the Daily Emerald.
How Eugene's Costs Compare
City figures suggest preservation is already cheaper than new construction. Eugene spends about $17,000 per unit to preserve existing affordable rental housing, compared with roughly $8,000 per unit to build new affordable rental and shared-equity housing, according to a city analyst cited by Lookout Eugene-Springfield. Research cited by KLCC found that similar tenant-purchase programs in Washington, D.C., and San Francisco have had success preserving affordable housing and preventing displacement, typically by pairing the purchase right with tenant education, counseling and financing support.
The National Low Income Housing Coalition reported that the District of Columbia, San Francisco and Philadelphia have each enacted some form of TOPA or right-of-first-refusal protection for renters. In Washington, D.C., the city's Department of Housing and Community Development provides assistance to tenant groups threatened with displacement when their apartment building is sold, according to the agency's own description of the program.
Next Steps for Eugene's Proposal
The work plan the council directed staff to prepare is expected to include prioritizing tasks, building a timeline and schedule, and assessing the financial implications of a TOPA policy, per the Daily Emerald. The council plans to bring that work plan back in February 2027. This marks the latest step in a process that began in February, when the council passed a 7-0 motion asking the city manager to return with more information on TOPA as a renter protection measure, according to earlier Daily Emerald reporting, which described the policy as allowing residents to form a coalition and purchase their building before third parties could.









