Portland/ Family & Kids

Photojournalist Follows Evelyn's Life After Twin's 2017 Death

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Photojournalist Follows Evelyn's Life After Twin's 2017 DeathSource: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons

Beth Nakamura once photographed Travis and Sarah Mitchell as they were sentenced. Years later, the same photojournalist followed the daughter who survived: Evelyn, nine in those later pictures, living a childhood her twin never had.

Nakamura, a senior staff photojournalist with The Oregonian in Portland, tells that return in a story published Tuesday, a collaboration with ProPublica. She was assigned to the sentencing about eight years ago. Eight years after the hearing, she began documenting Evelyn with Marshall and Jennifer Phillips — baptism, home life, doctors' appointments — and the couple's path out of the Followers of Christ.

Prayer, Then a Police Order

Sarah Mitchell gave birth prematurely to twins in 2017. Ginnifer lived four hours. The Mitchells, members of the faith-healing sect outside Portland, turned to prayer rather than an emergency room. Under Followers of Christ doctrine, members rely on faith healing instead of medical care.

The family sought care for the surviving twin only after the county's deputy medical examiner arrived at the home birth and learned, though not right away, that Evelyn existed. Body-camera footage, cut into a video introduction by Oregonian video editor Teresa Mahoney, shows officers outside the grandparents' house in Oregon City. They urged, then ordered, reluctant relatives to take the struggling infant to the hospital. If the family would not, police said they would do it themselves.

The Household That Took Her

Within days of her birth, Evelyn was placed in the custody of Marshall and Jennifer Phillips and remained in their permanent care. The Phillipses had left the sect. The essay stays with that departure: a list of dances practiced with Marshall Phillips, a father-daughter dance, a birthday meal at McDonald's, her favorite restaurant, and the ordinary fact of a doctor's appointment.

Those pictures sit beside a criminal case that did not end in a dispute over what happened in 2017. Travis and Sarah Mitchell pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide in Ginnifer's death and to criminal mistreatment for failing to seek medical care for Evelyn. They received prison sentences of more than six years. Their lawyer told the judge the couple grieved Ginnifer's death and loved Evelyn. The medical care authorities said Evelyn needed had still required a deputy medical examiner and a police order.

In a legal filing in an ongoing custody case, the Mitchells criticized the Phillipses for allowing Evelyn to participate in the coverage. The published account does not say how that case stands.

An Exemption Oregon Took Off the Books

The Oregon City-based Followers have a longer count than one night in 2017. ProPublica reported that 18 children of the group died between 1989 and 1999. Oregon fully removed its faith-healing exemption in 2011. Oregon prosecutors and detectives later told OPB that more parents chose medical care for their children after the change.

The Oregonian ties subsequent changes in state law to a reduction in child deaths related to faith healing. Since Ginnifer's death, ProPublica reports, one child among Oregon's Followers has died from lack of medical care, and deaths of children in the Followers have become an anomaly.

Across the State Line

The same reporting draws a hard line at Idaho, where the Followers have a handful of churches and the law still protects parents who rely only on faith healing. ProPublica reported that at least 15 babies and children from the faith-healing sect died between 2015 and 2025 of illnesses doctors could have successfully treated. ProPublica's records show that at least five sets of parents in the Idaho sect had lost multiple children.

Evelyn's checkup is not a small detail next to that ledger. It is the thing the doctrine ruled out, and the thing Oregon's 2011 change made a prosecutor's business when parents refused it.