
A unanimous vote by Evanston's Preservation Commission has, for now, stopped JPMorgan Chase from tearing down a 47-year-old bank branch on Central Street that was designed by an architect who trained under Ludwig Mies van der Rohe. Commissioners voted 9-0 Wednesday night to find the one-story brick-and-glass building at 1900 Central St. worthy of landmark designation, pausing Chase's plan to demolish it and put up a new branch in its place.
The building was designed by David Haid, who studied under Mies at the Illinois Institute of Technology and later worked in Mies's Chicago office before building the Evanston bank in 1979 for FirstBank, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. JPMorgan Chase acquired the branch after FirstBank, the paper reports, and has since argued the aging structure should come down rather than be repaired. As the Daily Northwestern reported, commissioners unanimously voted to direct staff to draft a formal report on whether the 47-year-old building, designed by Haid, should become a historic landmark.
Chase has proposed demolishing the existing 1979 structure and replacing it with a similarly scaled, single-story prototypical branch bank building, according to Evanston RoundTable. A city site plan filed with Evanston identifies the proposed replacement building at approximately 4,558 square feet. The bank's case for demolition rests heavily on the building's physical condition.
Chase Cites Corrosion, Preservationists Cite Design Pedigree
Per the Daily Northwestern's report, Chase said a structural evaluation found significant corrosion and deterioration, with repairs estimated to exceed $3 million. A separate account from Evanston Now described the repair need simply as $3 million rather than a figure exceeding that amount. Kenneth Colliander, a JPMorgan Chase vice president and architect, testified alongside preservation consultant George Kisiel of Okrent Kisiel Associates that the branch's exposed steel structure is weathered, rusted and needs at least $3 million in repairs, the Sun-Times reports.
Kisiel told commissioners that neither the building nor Haid is sufficiently distinguished to merit landmarking, describing the structure as failing on innovation, rarity, uniqueness and overall design quality, according to the Sun-Times. Commission members rejected that argument from Colliander and Kisiel, the paper reports, siding instead with supporters who pointed to the building's architectural lineage.
Commission member Stuart Cohen, an architect who co-founded the Chicago Seven design collective in the 1970s, said the work of Mies's disciples, including Haid's, carries real importance, and that few structures like the Central Street bank are still being built or still remain, per the Sun-Times account. An Evanston Office of Historic Preservation report characterized Haid's bank as a refined expression of the Second Chicago School during the late-modern period, the paper notes. Philip Castillo, an Evanston resident and managing director at architecture firm JAHN, told commissioners the building's steel roof rests on just four columns, creating a column-free interior, according to the Sun-Times.
Haid's Broader Body of Work
Resident Jim McKee, who researched the building's history and recommended it for designation, argued the branch is a significant example of modernist architecture and of Haid's body of work, Evanston RoundTable reports. Haid's other projects include the Ben Rose House auto pavilion, which later appeared in “Ferris Bueller's Day Off,” as well as Walter H. Dyett High School for the Arts, designed with Kenneth Childers, and his own Evanston residence, per the Sun-Times. Haid died in 1993 at age 64, the paper reports.
McKee told commissioners that Chase should view the designation as an opportunity rather than a setback, saying the company could turn the branch into a source of community pride and goodwill that attracts customers, according to the Sun-Times. He framed the moment as a chance for the bank to embrace its own history on Central Street rather than erase it.
A Pattern Beyond Evanston
JPMorgan Chase's broader real estate decisions suggest a company willing to spend heavily on its buildings elsewhere. The bank is spending $800 million to renovate Chase Tower at 10 S. Dearborn St. in Chicago, and according to the Wall Street Journal, as cited by the Sun-Times, it spent $6 billion to demolish its 52-story 1960s New York City headquarters and build a taller replacement, which opened on the same site in 2025.
Jonathan Solomon, who heads the preservation group Preservation Future, has said Evanston protects a great deal of its nineteenth- and early twentieth-century architecture but comparatively little from the second half of the twentieth century, according to Evanston RoundTable. Solomon said buildings from that late-modern era can be especially vulnerable because they are old enough to be seen as dated and inefficient but not yet old enough to be widely valued, per the same report.
What Happens Next
Wednesday's meeting lasted nearly two hours, the Sun-Times reports, and the vote found that the branch meets two criteria for landmark designation. The commission's action does not grant final landmark status; it protects the building's exterior from demolition and unsympathetic alterations only until permanent status is formally granted, according to the Sun-Times. Evanston preservation staff must now prepare a report detailing the bank's architectural type and its architect's significance, with that report and a draft landmark resolution expected to come before the commission at a meeting in the coming months.
Evanston RoundTable reports that the vote on the formal landmark report is expected in December or January; assuming it passes, the nomination would then advance to the Evanston City Council for final votes on permanent landmark status. The city's own zoning memo had previously listed Chase's demolition and rebuilding plan as non-compliant, pending either additional information from the applicant or a future Planned Development application, with the landmark nomination review continued to Wednesday's meeting.









