Phoenix/ Crime & Emergencies

Flagstaff Man Unmasked as Texas Fugitive Wanted 25 Years for Child Indecency

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Flagstaff Man Unmasked as Texas Fugitive Wanted 25 Years for Child IndecencyCoronado High School — Reported Former Band Teacher's School
Google Street View

A man who authorities say spent roughly 25 years hiding in plain sight in Flagstaff under a false identity was arrested on Thursday, accused of being a Texas fugitive wanted since 2001 on a child indecency warrant. Thomas Crumpler, 61, was taken into custody by the U.S. Marshals Service, the Flagstaff Police Department, the FBI and the Coconino County Sheriff's Office, according to seed facts tied to the case. He had been living locally under the alias John McGregor for more than 25 years, officials said.

Crumpler was wanted on a Lubbock County, Texas, warrant accusing him of indecency with a child, according to fox7austin.com. The outlet reported that Crumpler had been living in Flagstaff under an alias for about 25 years before investigators finally tracked him down. As first reported by 12News, the U.S. Marshals Service Arizona said the arrest came more than 25 years after the alleged crime.

A Tip From Ohio Breaks the Case Open

The break in the case came just two days before the arrest. The Southern Ohio Fugitive Apprehension Strike Team, a U.S. Marshal task force, received a lead involving family connections in Ohio on Nov. 17, per fox7austin.com's reporting. From there, a Deputy U.S. Marshal with the agency's Cold and Complex Case Group connected Crumpler to the alias John Paul McGregor, and investigators approached him under the assumed name John McGregor before his arrest two days later.

The U.S. Marshals Service Arizona said the arrest will allow victims to finally move their case forward in court. U.S. Marshal Van Bayless put it directly, saying “this arrest means those victims will finally have their case move forward in court,” the station's report notes. Those victims first came forward in 2001, according to the seed facts in the case.

Allegations Trace Back to a Lubbock Classroom

The allegations against Crumpler date back a quarter-century. A July 24, 2008, report from KCBD identified him as a former high school band teacher at Lubbock-Cooper and Coronado High Schools. Investigators at the time said Crumpler befriended at least three teenage boys and allegedly gave them alcohol and showed them pornographic videos, per that same 2008 account.

In July 2008, local media outreach tried to run him down. KCBD reported that its NewsChannel 11 team partnered with Raycom Media sister stations in Ohio and along the East Coast to broadcast his picture and seek leads. But those efforts stalled. Lubbock County Sheriff's Major Don Carter said at the time, “There was some indication about the East Coast, and so far nothing has panned out,” according to KCBD's reporting.

Decades Later, the Trail Finally Led to Arizona

Instead of the East Coast or elsewhere, Crumpler had apparently settled in Flagstaff, living under the McGregor alias for most of those 25 years before the Ohio family lead finally connected the dots. The case underscores how long a cold fugitive search can run before a single tip changes everything, with investigators ultimately tracing a decades-old Texas warrant to an Arizona mountain town. No further details on his custody status or a scheduled court appearance were available at the time of this reporting.