Chicago/ Real Estate & Development

Former Lakeview Parish House Sells for $7.2M as Adaptive Reuse Deals Surge

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Former Lakeview Parish House Sells for $7.2M as Adaptive Reuse Deals Surge621 W. Belmont Ave. — Approximate Site of $7.2M Sale
Google Street View

A nearly century-old parish house in Chicago's Lakeview neighborhood has traded hands for $7.2 million, with the apartment building fully occupied at the time of sale. The property at 621 W. Belmont Avenue was built in 1926 as the parish house for St. Peter's Episcopal Church before being gutted and converted into apartments in 2021.

Interra Realty brokered the sale, according to Connect CRE, which reported that the building contains 19 apartment units and sold to a local private investor. The seller was identified as JAB Real Estate, described as a local developer, investor and operator. Interra Realty senior managing partner Joe Smazal and director Mark Dykstra represented both the buyer and the seller in the transaction, per the same report.

Not every account of the building agrees on exactly how many units it holds. Connect CRE's unit count matches a separate REJournals account of the 2021 conversion, which also puts the number at 19 apartments with quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances and other contemporary finishes. JAB Real Estate's own portfolio page, however, describes repurposing the parish house into 20 apartments, a figure that lines up with a 44th Ward development page describing a proposal to convert the parish hall into 20 residential dwelling units with no additions to either the parish hall or the church building itself. The discrepancy between the 19- and 20-unit counts is not resolved in the available records.

What the Renovation Involved

Whatever the final tally, the scope of the work is not in dispute. JAB Real Estate says the project involved a complete gutting of the structure and the creation of entirely new floor plans, with every apartment receiving new HVAC, plumbing, electrical systems, windows and finishes. Connect CRE's report describes the finished units as retaining vintage character alongside updated finishes, in-unit laundry and central air.

The building's location was central to the pitch to buyers. It sits in Chicago's Lakeview neighborhood near the retail, restaurant, nightlife and hospitality strip along Belmont Avenue and Halsted Street, and it's within walking distance of Wrigley Field and Belmont Harbor, according to the same Connect CRE report. Smazal said East Lakeview's rental fundamentals support investor demand for well-located multifamily properties, per the outlet.

A Broader Pattern of Church Conversions

The Belmont Avenue deal fits into a larger trend of former religious buildings becoming apartment stock across Chicago. REJournals reported that Interra brokered a comparable deal in 2024, the $8.175 million sale of the former synagogue at 5029 N. Kenmore Ave. in Uptown, a property that held 40 apartments following a 2016 conversion. The outlet also cited a 2024 paper estimating that roughly 1% of U.S. congregations close annually, which extrapolates to about 3,500 closures a year based on the 2020 U.S. Religion Census — a dynamic that has been feeding a pipeline of buildings available for residential reuse.

That pipeline shows up in the broader numbers, too. A Bisnow report found that adaptive-reuse projects were on pace to account for about 44% of all units delivered downtown in 2026, with 117 units already delivered and 823 more under construction. St. Peter's Episcopal Church and its adjoining parish house were themselves approved as official City of Chicago landmarks by City Council, according to a page published by the City of Chicago.

Lakeview's Apartment Market Keeps Heating Up

The sale also lands amid a stretch of strong multifamily activity in the neighborhood and citywide. Northmarq reported that Lakeview and nearby Rogers Park recorded the greatest year-over-year vacancy improvements among the Chicago submarkets it tracked in the second quarter of 2026, and that the city's multifamily transaction count in the first half of the year reached its highest level in more than a decade. Cap rates averaged 6.0% during that same first half, up 25 basis points from the prior year, the firm found.

Lakeview has drawn other recent big-ticket deals as well. Commercial Real Estate Direct reported that ICM Properties paid $31 million, or $430,556 per unit, for the 72-unit Medallion apartment property in the neighborhood earlier this month — a sign that investor appetite for Lakeview multifamily assets, whether repurposed church buildings or purpose-built apartment towers, has shown little sign of cooling.

Chicago-Real Estate & Development