
A Monroe County grand jury indicted three former employees of a Forsyth daycare on Monday, months after state regulators shut the facility down over allegations that toddlers were given Benadryl to make them sleep and were routinely handled with physical force. Kendasja Hughley, Cathy Stevick and Shelby Webb all worked at Forsyth Methodist Church Caring For Kids Daycare before the Georgia Department of Early Care and Learning pulled its license.
The indictment was confirmed by the Monroe County clerk, according to 13WMAZ, which reported that an indictment simply means there is enough evidence for charges to proceed — a probable-cause standard that is lower than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt bar prosecutors must clear at trial. As a report on the indictment lays out, Hughley was charged with six felony counts of cruelty to children, along with five counts of reckless conduct and seven counts of simple battery. Hughley was charged with seven counts of simple battery and five counts of reckless conduct.
Webb was charged with one felony count of first-degree cruelty to children and one misdemeanor count of simple battery, the outlet's report states. The indictment accuses her of pulling the arm of a child. Stevick, meanwhile, was charged with three misdemeanor counts of failing to report child abuse, according to the same report.
What the Indictment Alleges Happened Inside the Daycare
The indictment accuses Hughley of using physical force against children, including allegedly kicking a cot, per the report. DECAL's own investigation, described in a separate account, found that staff routinely handled two-year-olds roughly when they wrestled with them, including picking them up and throwing them onto their mats.
Parents told NBC News that their children seemed sluggish and not normal when picked up on multiple days, a pattern that fed into the state's investigation. The alleged Benadryl use occurred in April 2025. The over-the-counter medication's manufacturer does not recommend its use in children under age 6, the Yahoo report noted.
License Revoked After State Found Credible Reports of Abuse
Georgia's Department of Early Care and Learning revoked the daycare's license on April 7, 2025, after the agency said it found credible reports that staff had given toddlers Benadryl to make them sleep and routinely used physical force against children, according to the indictment report. The findings effectively shut the facility down.
The case against Hughley, Stevick and Webb will be prosecuted by the Houston County District Attorney's Office rather than local prosecutors, because of a conflict within the Towaliga Judicial Circuit, which normally handles crimes in Butts, Lamar and Monroe counties, the report states.
Similar Allegations Surfaced in a Separate Metro Atlanta Case
The Forsyth case echoes a separate indictment out of Hall County, where daycare owner Stacie Fuller Young and her daughter-in-law, Ptiery Verby-Sunshine Edge, were indicted on 11 counts of cruelty to children, according to WSB-TV. That indictment alleged 11 children were given diphenhydramine, commonly known as Benadryl, and two children were given melatonin. DECAL's investigation into Young began January 6, 2025, and the agency issued her a cease-and-desist order the following day, the station reported.









