Phoenix/ Politics & Govt

Fountain Hills Bans Flock Cameras for Good, Even Without One Installed

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Fountain Hills Bans Flock Cameras for Good, Even Without One InstalledTraffic Surveillance Camera
Alex Knight / Unsplash

Fountain Hills Town Council voted 5-2 Tuesday to permanently ban the town from acquiring or funding automatic license plate readers, a pre-emptive move that locks the door against Flock Safety-style surveillance before a single camera has ever gone up. The ordinance doesn't just block hardware purchases — it also bars the town from leasing, installing, operating, or hosting the devices, and it closes off a side door by prohibiting officials from simply buying license-plate-reader data or search services from outside vendors.

Mayor Gerry Friedel, Vice Mayor Rick Watts, Allen Skillicorn, Gayle Earle, and Hannah Larrabee voted in favor, while Brenda Kalivianakis and Peggy McMahon opposed the measure, according to AZ Family. Skillicorn, who drafted the ordinance, said it sets a strong example for other municipalities looking to ban AI surveillance cameras outright. Town officials told the outlet the restrictions on buying plate-reader data or search services were designed specifically to close loopholes that have weakened similar bans in other cities.

No Cameras, No Compromise

What makes Fountain Hills' ban notable is timing: the town never had license plate reading cameras to begin with. An earlier Fountain Hills Times report confirmed as much, stating plainly that the town did not operate any such devices before the vote. Rather than wait for a vendor pitch or a future council to consider installing cameras, this council chose to foreclose the possibility altogether.

That outcome followed weeks of back-and-forth. At an Oct. 6 meeting, the council voted 4-3 to table the proposed ordinance until Oct. 20, the Fountain Hills Times reported. After that Oct. 20 meeting, the council directed Peggy McMahon, Rick Watts, and Brenda Kalivianakis to gather input from the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office before any final vote, according to a separate report from the same outlet's coverage carried by YourValley.

A Statewide Pattern of Retreat

Fountain Hills joins a growing list of Arizona communities pulling back from license plate reader technology. Cave Creek, Flagstaff, Payson, Sierra Vista, South Tucson, Surprise, and Tempe all canceled Flock contracts earlier this year, and Sedona was the first Arizona city to suspend its cameras after residents protested. By September, Cottonwood and Payson ending their Flock programs had pushed the statewide tally of contract terminations to 11, according to KJZZ.

Not every city is walking away. Queen Creek's council instead voted unanimously to approve an ordinance governing ALPR use rather than banning it, KJZZ reported. Police Chief Randy Brice said the town's 47 installed cameras had assisted in more than 3,000 incidents since 2025, with 15 more cameras being installed and tested. Apache Junction has likewise continued using Flock technology, saying it has helped locate missing people and criminals, while Goodyear also continues operating its automated plate readers even as it investigates whether an officer misused the system.

Misuse Cases Fuel the Backlash

Several Arizona police misuse scandals have intensified scrutiny of the cameras statewide. Chandler shut down use of its 40 Flock cameras after a possible internal misuse case in which an officer admitted to tracking a family member and resigned before a formal investigation concluded. An Apache Junction officer also resigned after an internal investigation found he had misused the system to track his wife, and a Goodyear officer was placed on leave in July amid an ongoing investigation into whether he committed a criminal violation. An AZ Family investigation described the Apache Junction case as one of four Valley police departments caught in audits for inappropriate Flock camera use.

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes announced in August that her office would investigate Flock and similar surveillance and automated license-plate-reader systems, including those from Axon, which has become a provider for some cities moving away from Flock. Her review, as described by Arizona Mirror, will examine camera use, its effects on residents' privacy, and potential constitutional issues. Tempe police told the outlet they were ending their Flock contract outright and would not seek a replacement system.

Industry Braces for More Rules

Flock itself has acknowledged the shifting political ground. The company told the Arizona Capitol Times this month that it expects an onslaught of bills in 2027 aimed at regulating the technology and said it agrees further guardrails are needed, voicing support for state-by-state legislation rather than a patchwork of local bans.

The pushback isn't confined to Arizona. In California, the San Diego City Council voted unanimously to rescind the police department's authorization to use Flock technology, though the cameras will stay in place until the city finalizes a removal agreement with the company, per KPBS. Santa Ana's council voted 6-0 to terminate its contracts with Flock Group and Motorola Solutions, a move that will shut off roughly four dozen readers, according to the Los Angeles Times. Nearby Fullerton's council took a softer approach in October, voting to temporarily switch off its Flock system for six months rather than end it entirely.