Phoenix/ Crime & Emergencies

Phoenix Teen Stabbed 27 Times — Prosecutors Now Seek Death Penalty for Tolleson Suspect

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Phoenix Teen Stabbed 27 Times — Prosecutors Now Seek Death Penalty for Tolleson SuspectSource: Google Street View

Maricopa County prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against Randal Santillan if he is convicted of first-degree murder in the stabbing death of 18-year-old Yessenia Norman, whose body was found inside a Tolleson apartment in January. Norman was stabbed 27 times, according to Phoenix police investigators, in a killing that set off a multi-state manhunt before Santillan was captured nearly two weeks later in Mississippi.

A Death Notice Filed Against the Tolleson Suspect

The Maricopa County Attorney's Office intends to seek the death penalty against the 27-year-old Santillan if he is convicted of first-degree murder, according to FOX 10 Phoenix. Court documents cited by the station allege the state will argue Santillan committed the offense in an especially heinous, cruel or depraved manner, inflicted violence on Norman beyond what was necessary to kill her, and knowingly continued the attack after she was fatally injured or already dead. Prosecutors have also pointed to a prior serious-offense conviction; kidnapping is charged in the current indictment, while the sexual-exploitation matter is a separate case.

The state plans to rely on testimony from a medical examiner and a Maricopa County Attorney's Office blood-spatter expert during the guilt or aggravation phases of the case, per the FOX 10 report. Prosecutors have said they intend to call the same witnesses and use the same evidence disclosed in a previous notice.

How Norman Disappeared and Was Found

Norman was last seen leaving a transitional facility in Phoenix on Jan. 15, a facility that was contracted with the Arizona Department of Child Safety, according to the FOX 10 report. Friends told investigators she was going to meet someone she had connected with through a dating app. Accounts differ on when Norman was reported missing: azcentral.com reported her roommate reported her missing on Jan. 18 after she failed to return from a date with Santillan, while WLOX reported the date as Jan. 19.

Her body was found inside Santillan's Tolleson apartment on Jan. 28, Tolleson police said, according to the azcentral.com report. Court records show Santillan and his ex-wife were tenants of that apartment; his ex-wife had left him in December, per those same records. A previous FOX 10 report had noted that both the suspect's and victim's cell phones were in the area of Norman's residence the night she disappeared.

Tracked Across Five States Before an Arrest in Mississippi

Police said Santillan left Tolleson immediately after Norman's death, and license plate readers tracked his vehicle through New Mexico, Texas, Illinois, Missouri and Mississippi in the days that followed, according to the FOX 10 report. He was spotted and taken into custody in Biloxi on Feb. 6, the same account notes, on first-degree murder and kidnapping charges connected to Norman's death.

On the afternoon of Feb. 17, Santillan was extradited from the Harrison County Adult Detention Center in Gulfport, Mississippi, and arrested at Phoenix Deer Valley Airport without incident, according to court documents cited by the azcentral.com report. His bond was set at $1 million, with his next court appearance scheduled for Feb. 23, the same court documents said.

What a Death-Penalty Case Means in Maricopa County

Under Arizona law, a jury must find one or more aggravating circumstances before it can weigh whether mitigating factors are substantial enough to call for leniency, according to A.R.S. § 13-751. That statutory standard governs how capital cases proceed, though it does not determine the outcome of Santillan's case.

Maricopa County has pursued capital charges in nearly 350 cases over the past 20 years, with only 13% ending in a death sentence, according to reporting from ProPublica. The county's courts have also begun ordering settlement conferences between prosecution and defense two years after a death-penalty notice is filed, per the same reporting, which also found the cost of providing an adequate defense in the county's capital cases since 2007 has totaled $289 million, not counting prosecution costs. Arizona resumed executions in 2025 after a two-year pause, according to ProPublica.