Memphis/ Politics & Govt

Germantown Schools Chief Says Lawmakers Lied as Vouchers Threaten Funding

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Germantown Schools Chief Says Lawmakers Lied as Vouchers Threaten Funding3350 Forest Hill Irene Rd — Reported Germantown Schools Funding Dispute
Google Street View

Germantown Schools Superintendent Jason Manuel this week accused Tennessee lawmakers of lying to the public about the impact of the state's school voucher program, warning that public education funding could take a hit once declining lottery participation is factored in. Manuel's comments, made earlier in the week, add his voice to a growing chorus of public school officials pushing back against the state's expanding voucher system.

Manuel said legislators had “lied to us” by claiming public education would not lose funding because of vouchers, but that losses are possible when voucher spending combines with decreased participation in the state lottery, according to the Daily Memphian. Tennessee's voucher program allows students to use government funds to attend private schools, and Manuel also said private schools accepting those public dollars are allowed to discriminate, per the same report. His remarks continued a trend of public school officials criticizing the voucher program, the Daily Memphian noted.

A Lottery System Already Under Strain

Manuel's warning lands against a backdrop of real financial pressure on the lottery-funded scholarships that have long been bundled into Tennessee's education funding conversations. In 2025, the state's 13 lottery-funded scholarship programs spent $505 million supporting 169,412 students, marking the first year lottery proceeds fell short of covering that scholarship spending, according to a report covered by Tennessee Lookout.

An analysis from Think Tennessee found net lottery proceeds available for scholarships fell 21.9% between fiscal years 2022 and 2025, even as scholarship spending grew 23.4% and the number of students relying on those scholarships rose 25.5%, according to WPLN. The station reports that this gap is projected to persist through fiscal year 2030. Tennessee Lookout's report similarly projects lottery proceeds falling short of scholarship-program costs every year through 2030, with a potential shortfall of up to $344 million by fiscal year 2030.

Backup Funds Redirected Elsewhere

Compounding the squeeze, a 2025 legislative deal redirected sports-gambling proceeds that had previously served as backup funds for the lottery's college scholarship program toward K-12 school construction and maintenance instead, per the same Tennessee Lookout report. Annual transfers of lottery surplus funds to Tennessee Promise are now capped at $10 million, a steep drop from transfers that ranged between $124 million and $151 million between 2022 and 2025, the outlet notes.

Voucher Expansion Adds to the Uncertainty

Tennessee lawmakers have also voted to increase the number of available vouchers from 20,000 to 35,000, according to WPLN's reporting. Separately, a voucher expansion bill saw differing seat counts move through the legislature this year: the House version proposed 35,000 seats, while the Senate version called for 40,000 total seats the following year, Chalkbeat reported.

What the Fiscal Note Says

A fiscal note attached to the legislation, filed with the Tennessee General Assembly, spells out a specific risk for districts like Germantown. Beginning in fiscal year 2027-28, local education agencies may not realize certain future increases in TISA funding to the extent that additional Education Freedom Scholarships increase transfers from public to private schools. The fiscal note states that existing hold-harmless protections maintain prior-year funding levels but do not account for future increases that would otherwise result from enrollment growth or increases in TISA funding levels.