Bay Area/ Oakland/ Weather & Environment

Groups Sue Over Gray Whale Finding Five Days Before Deadline's First Anniversary

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Groups Sue Over Gray Whale Finding Five Days Before Deadline's First AnniversaryOakland City Hall Plaza — Oakland City Hall Weather Backdrop
Google Street View

Three conservation groups sued the U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service on Nov. 17, asking a judge to make the agency do the one thing a 2025 petition already put on the calendar: decide whether Eastern North Pacific gray whales need Endangered Species Act protection again.

The Center for Biological Diversity said the service was supposed to issue an initial finding on that petition by Nov. 22, 2025, and did not. The groups frame the case as a challenge to a Trump administration delay. The statutory first step remained unanswered, and the suit came five days before the deadline’s first anniversary.

Courthouse News Service reported that the plaintiffs want a federal judge to find the service violated the Endangered Species Act and to order it to finalize a 90-day finding. That finding is the opening screen, not a listing. Oasis Earth, the International Marine Mammal Project and Earth Island Institute are represented by Greenfire Law, PC, a public-interest environmental firm in Berkeley. Oasis Earth is based in Anchorage.

A Finding That Never Arrived

The lawsuit also alleges the service did not answer, within 60 days, the groups' Aug. 25 notice of intent to sue. Federal listing law is built as a sequence of clocks. Miss the first one and the rest of the process never starts.

Rick Steiner of Oasis Earth said federal law requires listing and protecting the whales regardless of an administration's political ideology. Miyoko Sakashita of the Center for Biological Diversity said the administration is required to act and that protections are needed to help the whales. The packet includes no response from the Fisheries Service to the new case.

Delisted in 1994, Thin Again

Eastern North Pacific gray whales were protected under the Endangered Species Act until they were declared recovered and delisted in 1994. The groups now say that population has declined by as much as 50% over the past decade. In 2025, they say, only 85 calves were counted during the migration, the lowest number in 30 years.

Most of the recently dead whales were emaciated, the announcement says, likely because Arctic warming limited their prey. The groups describe that prey as amphipods and other small seafloor animals whose food chain begins with sea ice. Earlier melt and later freeze, they say, leave less algae and zooplankton on the bottom, and fewer of those animals for whales to eat before the migration south. That is the groups' explanation, not a finding that warming is the only cause of the decline.

Ships and fishing gear are the other documented hazards. Many whales, the announcement says, die after being hit or entangled. Scientists regard the beach counts as an undercount because most dead whales sink and are never recorded.

The November announcement, citing the Fisheries Service, put West Coast strandings at at least 192 gray whales so far in 2026. An Alaska Beacon report from August, written when the groups were still taking steps toward a suit, said 187 had been found dead along the Pacific coast that year, including 22 in Alaska. Different dates, coasts and cutoffs. Neither figure is a complete census of whales that died at sea.

What the Agency's Own Surveys Show

A NOAA Fisheries technical memorandum estimated Eastern North Pacific gray whale abundance at 17,750 during the 2025/2026 southbound migration, with a 95% confidence interval of 15,930 to 20,530. NOAA cautioned that recent apparent increases exceed the estimated maximum productivity rate. Factors other than births and deaths, the report says, must be affecting the count of whales passing the central California coast. Survey methods, analysis and migratory behavior are all on that list.

The same memorandum ties abundance swings to the availability of, and access to, benthic prey in the Arctic Ocean. That is the agency's own language sitting next to the groups' prey story, without settling how much of the decade's decline any one estimate captures. The memorandum discusses survey seasons, methods and multiple estimates.

There is a second official marker that does not match the urgency in the lawsuit. NOAA Fisheries said on May 19, 2026, that the unusual mortality event for stranded Eastern North Pacific gray whales had ended. It ran from Dec. 17, 2018, through Nov. 9, 2023. Closing that event did not produce the listing finding the petition sought, and it did not stop 2026 strandings from being counted.

Mark J. Palmer of the International Marine Mammal Project of Earth Island Institute said the decline could wipe out the entire population in as soon as 10 years if current conditions continue. That is his warning, not a projection the agency has adopted.

If the groups win, the immediate result is still paperwork with a legal name: a 90-day finding the statute dated for last November. A listing, if one ever comes, would be a later decision. For now the whales have a closed mortality event, a Berkeley lawsuit and an initial finding that never showed up.